What is the worst experience you've ever had in a mafia game?

Nabber

Artisanal Cheese Taster
I know I definitely hated having to defend Bop from that trap laid Day 2 in Kid Icarus Mafia, it was really annoying knowing exactly what happened and not being able to prevent it.
 

Time Turner

You are filled with determination. (R/GD/TT)
Pronouns
He/him
Gundam Tanaka said:
I know I definitely hated having to defend Bop from that trap laid Day 2 in Kid Icarus Mafia, it was really annoying knowing exactly what happened and not being able to prevent it.
You really didn't do much of a good job at defending him.

For me... Tucayo's Mafia. Everyone's attitude as they were picking the Mafia off infuriated me. Not because I was Mafia myself, but because they essentially said, "Fuck you" to us.
 

Nabber

Artisanal Cheese Taster
Time Turner said:
Gundam Tanaka said:
I know I definitely hated having to defend Bop from that trap laid Day 2 in Kid Icarus Mafia, it was really annoying knowing exactly what happened and not being able to prevent it.
You really didn't do much of a good job at defending him.

For me... Tucayo's Mafia. Everyone's attitude as they were picking the Mafia off infuriated me. Not because I was Mafia myself, but because they essentially said, "Fuck you" to us.
What was I supposed to say? I pointed out rather well that there was no way anyone could check Bop and send a message to a player that wasn't even confirmed innocent on the same night...
Xerneas said:
Forum's Choice Mafia.

Unless I get revived.
hey that's not my fault, someone's gotta die night 1
 

Time Turner

You are filled with determination. (R/GD/TT)
Pronouns
He/him
Gundam Tanaka said:
Time Turner said:
Gundam Tanaka said:
I know I definitely hated having to defend Bop from that trap laid Day 2 in Kid Icarus Mafia, it was really annoying knowing exactly what happened and not being able to prevent it.
You really didn't do much of a good job at defending him.
What was I supposed to say? I pointed out rather well that there was no way anyone could check Bop and send a message to a player that wasn't even confirmed innocent on the same night...
You could have role claimed to BMB, who was just recently revived from the time travel, and he could have called off the lynch. That was probably your best shot.
 

Lily x

Goodbye
Pronouns
She/her
MP6 mafia, as I was on holiday so had a hard job keeping up with it, V2W mafia for the same as MP6, but due to not playing much v2w, I couldn't find a decent claim, STHM as I died night 1 for no reason :/. Plus everything Pre-Majoras Mafia.
 

Smasher

Smasher
Forum Moderator
Chat Operator
Awards Committee
Former 'Shroom Staff
Pronouns
She/her
MarioWiki
Smasher
LTQ's second game.

Lynched on day one with Random.org with the only vote on me being placed by a mafia member on dumb reasoning.

Enough said.
 

NSY

Celestial Guide
Pronouns
He/him
Day vs Night mafia.

I think you already know why.
 

Nabber

Artisanal Cheese Taster
Meowth said:
LTQ's second game.

Lynched on day one with Random.org with the only vote on me being placed by a mafia member on dumb reasoning.

Enough said.
oh yeah that reminds me in Spirit Tracks Mafia where I was lynched Day 1 off a joke vote who was also mafia

and I was the cop
 

Not Shane

The Man With No Custom Title
Chat Operator
Retired Forum Mod
Retired Wiki Staff
Former 'Shroom Staff
Pronouns
He/him
doesn't the other topic fufil this purpose?

either way, again, awards mafia ii, wasn't bad game at all, but lynched day 1, no tokens, :(
 

NSY

Celestial Guide
Pronouns
He/him
Until you ran into Granny Smasher.
 
Pronouns
He/him
NSY said:
Day vs Night mafia.

I think you already know why.
It was my favorite, and I think you already know why.

Lilith said:
Plus everything Pre-Majoras Mafia.
If you love Majora's Mafia, just marry it. Geez LilyxMajora's Mafia otp. :P

Time Turner said:
Gundam Tanaka said:
Time Turner said:
Gundam Tanaka said:
I know I definitely hated having to defend Bop from that trap laid Day 2 in Kid Icarus Mafia, it was really annoying knowing exactly what happened and not being able to prevent it.
You really didn't do much of a good job at defending him.
What was I supposed to say? I pointed out rather well that there was no way anyone could check Bop and send a message to a player that wasn't even confirmed innocent on the same night...
You could have role claimed to BMB, who was just recently revived from the time travel, and he could have called off the lynch. That was probably your best shot.
Bop was mafia? I don't remember him being mafia...
 

Time Turner

You are filled with determination. (R/GD/TT)
Pronouns
He/him
Xerneas said:
Time Turner said:
Gundam Tanaka said:
Time Turner said:
Gundam Tanaka said:
I know I definitely hated having to defend Bop from that trap laid Day 2 in Kid Icarus Mafia, it was really annoying knowing exactly what happened and not being able to prevent it.
You really didn't do much of a good job at defending him.
What was I supposed to say? I pointed out rather well that there was no way anyone could check Bop and send a message to a player that wasn't even confirmed innocent on the same night...
You could have role claimed to BMB, who was just recently revived from the time travel, and he could have called off the lynch. That was probably your best shot.
Bop was mafia? I don't remember him being mafia...
You were an Innocent for a brief period, and in that period, Nabber could have role claimed to you.

you don't need to rub it in either
 

MCS

Donkey Kong
Pronouns
He/him
Time Turner said:
For me... Tucayo's Mafia. Everyone's attitude as they were picking the Mafia off infuriated me. Not because I was Mafia myself, but because they essentially said, "Fuck you" to us.
Very much this.

Anyways, quoting from another thread:

MCS said:
[...]my worst moment was definitely either Magnificent Mafia, where 1) I accidentally made the wrong roleclaim and 2) I was suspected just because I asked why IceShadow blatantly said he was mafia, and that made no sense to me; or Tucayo Mafia, where everyone was so sure I was mafia, they just decided to ignore everything I said including my false roleclaim, which in retrospect could have been a little better if my mafia buddies actually helped me with it.
 

EctoBiologist

Best cat themed touhou. I love touhou and DR.
Banned User
Pronouns
She/her
being the granny in any game.

now boy that is sure my worst experience!
 

Nabber

Artisanal Cheese Taster
Sylveon said:
being the granny in any game.

now boy that is sure my worst experience!
heh, that reminds me of Simpsons Mafia

good times, good times
 

Not Shane

The Man With No Custom Title
Chat Operator
Retired Forum Mod
Retired Wiki Staff
Former 'Shroom Staff
Pronouns
He/him
Sylveon said:
being the granny in any game.

now boy that is sure my worst experience!
let's see...mlp mafia...vote to lynch too, iirc?

and that's just my games
 

General Neptune

Lafayette Quenchingly-McQuaffin
Pronouns
Use name
Pretty much any time someone suspects me of being scum. I know it's just a game, but I gotta say it sticks a dagger in my heart.

One of the worst has to be Day vs. Night Mafia. So I'm the solar doctor. BMB is the lunar doctor. He leads a lynch against me, and even after my whole "lynch BMB because he's lunar" and my ultimate lynch, everyone decided "well BMB must be solar, he's the one who bandwagon'd our doctor with little to no evidence"

seriously

I mean seriously, was it that hard to figure out

seriously

guys
 
Pronouns
He/him
Mario Party 9 Mafia on Night 1. I wasn't really paying attention, I could have saved our Doctor if had been.

Sure we ended up winning but I still felt like I caused us a serious disadvantage.
 

Time Turner

You are filled with determination. (R/GD/TT)
Pronouns
He/him
You guys lost the cop, the doctor, and the Roleblocker, all in the first phase, but there weren't enough possibilities for a role claim, so the Mafia got screwed over.
 
Top