Mafia Tiering Discussion Thread

[Smashley]

Oh, also...Stooben, are you going to do another tier-list that you did before MWIII?

I wasn't thinking of doing that. I guess I could if people wanted me to, but I don't want to cause any hurt feelings if people don't like their spot on the list. How well one does can be entirely situational, anyway.

I was just starting to play when you last did the tiers. I'd personally be interested to see where I'd be put now that I've been playing for nearly two years.

 

[Baby Mario Bloops]

I was just starting to play when you last did the tiers. I'd personally be interested to see where I'd be put now that I've been playing for nearly two years.

I found the list to be fun and actually motivating. I mean, it makes you want to climb up the list. I think I was at Tier C last time, and it really made me want to move up the list, which actually helped me do really good in some mafia games during MWIII, like Wind Waker Mafia.

 

[Lily x]

I was just starting to play when you last did the tiers. I'd personally be interested to see where I'd be put now that I've been playing for nearly two years.

I think you would be on A or whatever is highest
Last time I was on F, though I hope now I am on about B, going by how much I improved.

 

[Tyrell Badd]

I more than likely fell because I haven't done jack shit in any recent mafia games.

 

[Hobbes]

Tiers would be nice

 

[RandomYoshi]

I think I'd be able to archive a guaranteed C or B on the rankings, though it wouldn't surprise me if I got an A. <_>

 

[Smashley]

I was just starting to play when you last did the tiers. I'd personally be interested to see where I'd be put now that I've been playing for nearly two years.

I think you would be on A or whatever is highest

Heh, thanks.

I think I'd be able to archive a guaranteed C or B on the rankings, though it wouldn't surprise me if I got an A. <_>

I could see you getting C, and possibly B, but looking at who was on the original list, I honestly don't think that you'd be at A quite yet.

 

[RandomYoshi]

Well anything better than a D is awesome for me. I haven't played Mafia that much, so I'm still inexperienced with some stuff.

[insert remark on how short the Days are here and how voting somebody just because the person who you are voting is voting you is stupid]

 

[NSY]

I don't really want to be on the list due to me being scummy in most past mafia games.

 

[RandomYoshi]

Well you are a somewhat good scum player, though - you managed to win Yoshi K's game without being too suspicious.