Mario Sports Mix

NSY

Celestial Guide
This game is just underrated, full stop.
 
I've always wondered if it was any good, looked okay from screens and the trailer but dunno otherwise.
 
Tempest Tales said:
I'm disappointed this game with no unlockable Mario characters. Toss the Mario Hoops 3-on-3.
How can a roster ruin a game.
 
NSY said:
Tempest Tales said:
I'm disappointed this game with no unlockable Mario characters. Toss the Mario Hoops 3-on-3.
How can a roster ruin a game.

It really depends if there are differences between the characters, such as movesets, stats, moves, etc.

But this isn't an action or fighting game so I think he's overreacting.
 
I dunno. The lack of Waluigi was a deal breaker for some people in regards to Mario Kart 7.
 
Doomie said:
I dunno. The lack of Waluigi was a deal breaker for some people in regards to Mario Kart 7.

I think it was more of the fact that there were far worse characters in his place, which kinda made no sense.
 
Doomie said:
I dunno. The lack of Waluigi was a deal breaker for some people in regards to Mario Kart 7.
Do you mean some people almost forgot Toadette and Birdo weren't in too?

In this topic the biggest critiscism is for Birdo and Dixie who were tossed from Hoops 3-on-3.

NSY said:
How can a roster ruin a game.
The other concern is that if a home console could have a roster smaller than a handheld one. The number of roster is also littler than many other Mario sport spinoffs while it isn't really a complex game.
 
The gameplay of this game is far superb. Everything moves smoothly and where you want it. All characters also have their own quirks when performing the same attacks. I really like that. It shows that Square really does care about the game and that they're not rushing through it. I find Speedy characters a bit broken in Hockey, though. But, I found fun with all sports, and the Party games are very fun too. For a game that features multiple sports in one, Square did this job right. All the sports have much depth into it, which is hard to find in games with multiple sports/stuff in it.

What I didn't like was the poor character roster. Sure, it's a sports game, but the roster is even weaker than Mario Hoops 3-on-3, which is very baffling. Fly Guy, Dixie Kong, Paratroopa, Boo, and Birdo are all scrapped and Mii, Toad, and Slime were the only ones that got added. Toad is the only new Mario character, which does not even barely compensate for the major cuts. That's bad; you started out with even less than your precedent. What I especially didn't like was that all unlockable characters were Final Fantasty characters, and no where in the game box except for hints of Square Enix in the box assumes that Final Fantasy characters are about a 1/3 of the roster. They were pretty fine in Mario Hoops 3-on-3 as a surplus addition, but with a roster that has many cuts on the Mario portion rather than additions, in a game called Mario Sports Mix, is unforgivable.

The bad character roster really shows when you're trying to select a team. Most of us use a team of 3 characters. Sometimes, we are pretty dynamic and we want to choose other characters we like in the game. Except that you can't. You can't really change your team unless you really love all characters, which most often isn't the case. The roster could use more potential, especially since every character is actually unique, thanks to the differing animations and movements.

In other cases, we do get nice things such as outfit changes or awesome recolors, but it applies to only certain characters and we can't even choose many of them for the same team. While it's an inconvenience at best, the game is perfectly capable of doing this since you encounter teams of Toads in tournament mode, which makes it no excuse to not have an option at that.
 
Baby Luigi said:
What I especially didn't like was that all unlockable characters were Final Fantasty characters, and no where in the game box except for hints of Square Enix in the box assumes that Final Fantasy characters are about a 1/3 of the roster.
I don't care FF characters, though I agree that at least one Mario player should be unlockable.

Another topic is that the FF representives are not "characters" at all. If SE want fans to buy, Chocobo, Lightning, or Cloud might have better effects.
 
Dorayaki said:
Doomie said:
I dunno. The lack of Waluigi was a deal breaker for some people in regards to Mario Kart 7.
Do you mean some people almost forgot Toadette and Birdo weren't in too?
The point is that Toadette and Birdo are never "standard" characters. They're usually on and off while Waluigi has been there since Mario Tennis 64 and has been in almost, if not every, Mario spin-off while the other haven't. Suddenly, they drop Waluigi for what: a Mario recolor and a minor character that literally appears for like 3 minutes in both Galaxy games.