So let's logically analyze Nabber's position here:
(i'm sorry if i'm putting words into your mouth this is the only way i could get it to be logically valid so i could refute your premises. if what i've said is a poor statement of your position then go back and rethink your argument again)
Nabber's Position
Proposition: IF Turb should have asked to put her game on the schedule, IF Uniju had wanted to sign up for one of Turb's mafia games, THEN he would have signed up for Turb's completely themeless mafia back in February.
Proposition: IF Turb had asked to have her game on the schedule AND Uniju had signed up for Turb's mafia, THEN Uniju would have been able to sign up for and play Turb's mafia.
Proposition: IF this mafia was the mafia Uniju was referring to, THEN Turb should have asked to have her put game on the schedule.
Assumption: This is the mafia Uniju was referring to.
Therefore: Turb should have asked to have her game put on the schedule
Therefore: IF Uniju had wanted to sign up for one of Turb's mafia game, THEN he would have signed up for Turb's completely themeless mafia back in February.
Therefore: Uniju would have been able to sign up for and play Turb's mafia.
A Logical Refutation of Nabber's Position
Proposition: IF this is not the mafia Uniju was talking about, THEN Uniju would not have been able to sign up for and play Turb's mafia.
Proposition: IF this is not the game Uniju was talking about, THEN the only reason Uniju has not played in Turb's mafia is due to the restrictive schedule.
Fact: This is not the game Uniju was talking about.
Evidence:
Uniju said:
Nabber said:
That's not what I was talking about
Therefore: Turb should not have asked to have her game put on the schedule.
Therefore: The only reason Uniju has not played in Turb's mafia is due to the restrictive schedule.
Therefore: The rest of Nabber's argument is of indeterminable truth value, while the only reason Uniju has been robbed of the fun of playing in Turb's mafia is the restrictive schedule.
Quod Erat Demonstrum