Which Melee character (that is not in brawl) should be in the next SSB game

Which Melee character (that is not in brawl) should be in the next SSB game

  • Mewtwo

    Votes: 11 45.8%

  • Dr.Mario

    Votes: 3 12.5%

  • Young Link

    Votes: 2 8.3%

  • Pichu

    Votes: 3 12.5%

  • Roy

    Votes: 5 20.8%
  • Total voters
    24
YoshiMonsta

YoshiMonsta

Yoshi! Yoshi!
Which of the characters in Melee that aren't in Brawl should be in the in the next game, honestly why should any of them. The reason they got rid of the, was kind of that they are fail characters, nobody liked them, but I no a lot of people who would disagree though. Would You? And do you think any of them should be put in the spotlight. And if so, please write which moves should be changed of that character and (if possible) which move it should be replaced by.
 
I think Young Link should have returned. Instead of making him get his clone Link moveset, he should get his Majora's Mask moveset (utilizing transformation masks such as Deku, Goron, and Zora). I know Toon Link exists, but Toon Link could also get another moveset as well, putting Windwaker into perspective. Plus, Young Link's inclusion could support the remake for Majora's Mask on the 3DS (if there will be any in the first place).

And, personally, Young Link was my secondary in Melee, after Ness.

Mewtwo should have NEVER been cut in the first place. Seriously.
 
Pichu was and still is my Melee main, so of course I would vote for him. Unfortunately, he's given a lot more competition this time around so I must admit that it would be difficult to see Pichu return this time around. Perhaps making Pichu as an alt for Pikachu would at least satisfy the Pichu fans.

Other than Pichu, I'd say Mewtwo is perhaps the only one that deserves to be brought back. There was no reason for his cut other than time constraints (and possibly the amount of Pokemon characters slots) as Mewtwo is still relevant to this day. I have a good feeling that he will return in SSB4 due to the amount of fans wanting him to return as well as the fact that he had the most data created out of the forbidden 7 in Brawl.
 
Out of all these. Mewtwo for sure. Nintendo could improve him and I think it'd be kinda unique to have a character that was missing for one game but then came back. Mewtwo could be played as making a "grand return". Although it may not be possible.

As for Propeller Toad or any other Pichu fans, there is the theory that Brawl!Pikachu was once Melee!Pichu because the goggles that only Pichu had in Melee are an alt for Pikachu in Brawl. The Pikachu in 64/Melee according to this theory "retired" so to speak or perhaps became a Raichu. Of course it's only a theory that people may put in their headcanons if they liked Pichu. Although people who didn't like Pichu can just as easily say Pikachu stole Pichu's goggles. I'll admit I'm one of those who's glad Pichu didn't return, but I can hardly say I'd hate him enough to have a headcanon like that. (Both can be sort of dark interpretations too like the Melee Pichu is Brawl Pikachu could be that the ol' Pikachu died for some reason, or the other thing on stealing Pichu's goggles makes Pikachu look like a bully)
 
@Northern Verve

I'll add up to that theory. Pikachu can wall jump in Brawl, but in Melee and 64 he couldn't. However, Pichu was able to wall jump in Melee. ;)

Pikachu is alright to me in Brawl; however, there were still those small differences that made Pichu feel more different to me in Melee when compared to Pikachu (Pichu had some unique moves like his up and side smash, different varieties of Pikachu's specials). Regardless, I am fine with seeing a Pichu alt at least in SSB4.
 
Propeller Toad said:
@Northern Verve

I'll add up to that theory. Pikachu can wall jump in Brawl, but in Melee and 64 he couldn't. However, Pichu was able to wall jump in Melee. ;)
Click to expand...

Oh yeah I kinda forgot about that.
 
I think that none of them should exist for these reasons.

1. I think that Roy should never have existed, being less main in Fire Emblem then Ike. Also for the most important reason, they made him just as Agile as Marth. Having mainly different moves he should be on a different weight area.

2. Dr.Mario the biggest reason is obvious: He is a 2nd copy of Mario. You cannot have Mario, Luigi, Dr.Mario. Plus he was all the same except for the fireball move, which the idea of firing pills sucks. He should either have an entirely different move or a well thought out similar replacement one.

3. Young Link is a mistake, he is basically the same as Link. Which you would think the idea of a copy would need something more different the fire arrows. Toon Link is very different with agility and can easily top normal link, and you wouldn't think that link was stronger as s kid, would you?

4. Pichu is a copy of Pikachu and a bad idea for SSB games. He needs to be more different then just being able to wall jump and have different smash attacks. And don't give me the crap that says that he is more agile then Pikachu. Pikachu is already agile enough. And he has nothing to value over Pikachu, considering Pikachu can wall jump in Brawl he will not be lowered as a standard. And also, there is a whole lot of Pokemon already, who thinks that there should be a copy of a Pokemon?

5. Mewtwo is a pretty good idea but there are some flaws in his idea. In general you know he is a legendary right? But the standards set for a legendary is much higher, thanks to Brawl's http://www.mariowiki.com/Spear_Pillar. Leaving you expecting a legendary to be as powerful as Dialga or Palkia. And if a "legendary" can get defeated by a mere Pikachu or Jigglypuff alone then you have to wonder about the whole legendary idea. Making them all supposedly more powerful then a normal Pokemon would do no good to be a real character. If Mewtwo was to return though, it would help Pokemon a lot to make him a boss. Being more powerful then the ordinary Pokemon (like Rayquaza) would help his reputation.
 
YoshiMonsta said:
nobody liked them
Click to expand...

uh

Anyway, Roy was one of my favorite characters in Melee because I love to play as the Fire Emblem characters. I would love to have him back. Mewtwo would also be good to have. The other three I really don't care about, but I wouldn't mind having them back.