Bump, but something's been on my mind and I was curious about hearing other people's thoughts. Copying and pasting what I wrote on Reddit.
I always find it odd when people treat Gohan in different points of his life as different characters. The phrasing is a little bit weird, so let me explain. I often see people when listing their favorite Dragon Ball characters will include "Teen Gohan" (who's not even a teen, I wish that name would go away) as if he's a separate character from Gohan when he's on Namek or high school. Future Gohan I get because timelines. ScrewAttack's a pretty grievous example of this with them listing Buu saga Gohan as their least favorite character.
I don't know, when I say Gohan is one of my favorite characters, I mean him as a whole. Yes he acts differently in the Buu saga versus the way he does during the Cell Games, but that's just called character growth. He goes from practically a ten year old to high school student. He's gonna act a little differently. He matured and franjly became more interesting. I love the stuff with Gohan in high school and Saiyaman.
Not to sound aggressive and elitist with this, but i feel like a lot of "Teen" Gohan fans aren't Gohan fans. They like Super Saiyan 2, but they don't have a love for the character since the Cell Games is when he's out of character the most. Shitting on everything that came before and after for the character and only focusing on how "cool" Super Saiyan 2 was, I don't know it leaves a poor taste in my mouth. Don't get me wrong, the Super Saiyan 2 sequence is beautiful (at least in the Japanese, the English dub butchers it). I just feel like people should treat Gohan's character holistically and not view it in arbitrary chunks and age designations used for video games.