Wii U Game Dream Roster

Nintendo tries to avoid these ratings, and even most parenting sites agreed that Brawl was barely a T rating.
 
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time got an E rating, even with the well and Redeads (though they changed it to a T for the 3DS version). I thought Brawl should get the very most an E10+
 
Baby Luigi said:
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time got an E rating, even with the well and Redeads (though they changed it to a T for the 3DS version). I thought Brawl should get the very most an E10+
Click to expand...

Actually, OoT 3D is rated E10+.
 
My mistake. But I knew the rating got up for that game
 
MnSG said:
Baby Luigi said:
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time got an E rating, even with the well and Redeads (though they changed it to a T for the 3DS version). I thought Brawl should get the very most an E10+
Click to expand...

Actually, OoT 3D is rated E10+.
Click to expand...
IKR Brawl was totally not inappropriate.
 
Brawl isn't much worse than Super Smash Bros., you know
 
Brawl obviously got rated T for "Crude Humor". Blame the Wario Waft for that, since there's nothing else that would warrant the "Crude Humor" statement.
 
I kinda also think that Brawl was made Teen for Solid Snake and Zero Suit Samus. I wouldn't blame one fart move to be the reason why it ended up being Teen. Though I do wonder if Melee would of been E10+ if that rating was around back then, I would suppose so.
 
Kind of like the Indiana Jones movies are rated PG but these days would be rated PG-13. I heard that Indiana Jones and the Temple of Doom single-handedly created the PG-13 rating.
 
I don't remember where I got this info, (could've been a YouTube comment or from GameFAQS), but, someone said that Melee being rated T was probably due to violence against women since Peach and Zelda became playable and I personally think it could've also been due to animal cruelty (DK, Diddy, Yoshi, Sonic and the Pokemon), granted, DK, Yoshi, and Pikachu were playable in the original but the graphics made them look cartoony unlike in Melee and Brawl where the graphics are more realistic.
 
Raphael said:
I don't remember where I got this info, (could've been a YouTube comment or from GameFAQS), but, someone said that Melee being rated T was probably due to violence against women since Peach and Zelda became playable and I personally think it could've also been due to animal cruelty (DK, Diddy, Yoshi, Sonic and the Pokemon), granted, DK, Yoshi, and Pikachu were playable in the original but the graphics made them look cartoony unlike in Melee and Brawl where the graphics are more realistic.
Click to expand...

...That's kinda the first problem with that. Youtube commenters and GameFAQs aren't exactly known for being great sources. The only thing Nintendo did for Animal cruelty is change the appearance of the Topis, because I think in the Japanese version the Topis look more like Seals while they look much different in the American version. Also I can't be the only one that think it's silly that they'd mark it down past E just because women are playable in the roster. Have one fighting game with postively no blood with slapstick items and all the characters are male or are animals and it gets an E rating. Then suddenly the sequel adds a woman character or 2 and it's a little bit of a controversy that raises the rating. That's just silly.