Now this is a real tricky one. We have Sonic Rainboom against Read it and Weep.
This is of course one where we have an obvious similarity. Both of the episodes are Rainbow Dash episodes. And I'd also say that these are the best Rainbow Dash episodes of each season. (Even if of course Sonic Rainboom may have been Rainbow's ONLY sole episode in Season 1). But besides that there isn't much else. As one episode is about her getting nervous before a competition starts in Cloudsdale, and the other of her recuperating in the Hospital while learning the joys of reading. At the very least both of the episodes Rainbow gets worried about her reputation. If she utterly failed at the competition she worried she'd become the laughing stock of not only the bullies who laugh at her constantly but all of cloudsdale. And in the other episode she worries about coming out as an Egghead simply because now she likes books. These IMO are both pretty great episodes. So my personal tastes might be the one that ultimately decides it.
Sonic Rainboom is one of the instant classics of Season 1. Everybody remembers and enjoys Fluttershy's "Yay" and of course the Sonic Rainboom scene at the end. While it's pretty hard to believe given how popular she is. Rainbow Dash actually had some of the lowest screentime in Season 1. So it was about time she finally got her first episode that was for the most part centered around her. Rather then share it with Pinkie (Griffon the Brush-Off) or Applejack (Fall Weather Friends). And this was a pretty amazing episode showing Rainbow's psyche. If Twilight hadn't had the cloudwalking and flight spell, Rainbow Dash probably would of let her nerves get the best of her and she would of failed the competition. Fluttershy tried her best but it wouldn't have been enough if you get right down to it. This episode also showed both the best... and the worst... of Rarity. She convinces Twilight to somehow get them all up to Cloudsdale. Which ultimately helps Rainbow for the better. But when they get to Cloudsdale, Rarity's wings impress all the local Pegasi and she can't help but stroke her ego. Somuch so when a few Pegasi suggest that she enters the competition. She agrees, making Rainbow all the more nervous. It makes it hard for you decide what to think of Rarity in this particular episode. On one hand she gets Rainbow's friends there in the first place, on the other she made things worse by letting her ego and vanity go to her head and make things worse for her friend, but on another note her part in the competition ends up endangering her life and it gives Rainbow Dash the extra push in order to perform the Sonic Rainboom to save both her and the Wonderbolts that had tried to save Rarity themselves. At the very least though Rarity apologizes at the end. Cloudsdale is an awesome place in the episode. We didn't really see much of it other Discord showing it being collapsed or in Hurricane Fluttershy. But maybe there will be an episode where we see it again in Season 3 sometime. Maybe at the same time a little more history on Rainbow and Fluttershy. The "yay" scene is among the cutest of the entire series, and Fluttershy actually being the loudest of Rainbow's friends cheering is special in itself. The Pegasi bullies themselves however I find it hard to like, only coming around after Rainbow has successfully done her trick. The Sonic Rainboom and the Victory scene afterwards is one of the best episode endings in the series. There's nothing much else to say at this point.
As for Read It and Weep. It's quite an interesting episode. I don't know how many Season 2 episodes are considered classics quite yet. And I'm not entirely sure if Read It and Weep is considered one of them. But I gotta say that I do enjoy this one alot. Some of it for personal reasons. In contrast with Season 1, Rainbow Dash has had 2 episodes prior at this point in Season 2. One was pretty good while the other couldn't have really helped much. Being the first Rainbow episode since Mare-Do-Well there were some worries about how this episode would be like, as unfair as it might be. Anyway of course we know Rainbow Dash gets a minor sprain in her wing that will make her uncapable of Flying for a few days. Worried she'd get bored to death while just laying there in bed, she whines to her friends about it. Then comes Twilight with the one item that drives this episode along: A Daring Do book. Which Rainbow Dash is initially against (I don't know about you, but if Twilight was on the side of my hospital bed with that face she gives Rainbow she'd convince me to read ANY book). Before Twilight leaves she gives some choice words before heading out Rainbow Dash's room. Rainbow Dash then starts thinking of stuff to do that she easily gets bored of but apparently were better options at the time then actually trying out the book. Like hitting a ball, telling jokes to other patients, etc. Eventually she relents and starts reading in which she finds an instant connection with Daring when she reads that her Wings are injured. She reads on as the protagonist in the story meets danger from predators, cliffs, etc. and finds a temple that she was searching for. At this point Rainbow Dash admits to herself that he's loving the story and even says to herself "I love reading!" but then also says "I'm an egghead...". This kinda reminds me about how some Bronies were reluctant about the show before. If you replace the Daring Do book with a show or even an episode of Friendship is Magic and Egghead with Brony. Rainbow's situation can be held dear to those who felt reluctant before trying out the show. Thinking that the show is not for them because of their stubbornness. Then comes where Rainbow Dash, when visited by her friends that she likes the book. Sound familiar with any of you closet Bronies or former ones? Twilight suspects something is up when Rainbow is practically letting Fluttershy and her win Rainbow's favorite board game without even taking a turn and not even feeling the slightest sadness of losing. (Which if you remember Fall Weather Friends, she hates losing). And eats messy in order to get Rarity, Applejack, and Pinkie Pie out afterwhich. I also gotta say that I love the whole Daring Do thing. I'm a big fan of the Indiana Jones series, and to see an obvious reference to it in Friendship is Magic was ultimately awesome. Even if before the episode I thought it would mean we'd get multiple book or movie parodies instead of just one. But still it's fine. Everything from the forests, the character, the temple, and of course the placement of the treasure was a huge homage to Indy. Sometime near the end just when stuff was getting good for Rainbow, the Doctor tells her that it's time to leave. And unfortunately they take her out without the book. Which leads her to try to get back in so she can get the book. Faking an injury doesn't work, so she then tries sneaking in at night. Which shows Ponyville hospitals have some tight security it seems as they chase Rainbow into town for stealing what they think were slippers. Eventually Rainbow is led to a stop at the Treebrary where she finally tells all that she likes the book and reading. Reading to a neat scene between Rainbow and Twilight (Those 2 haven't interacted that much before this point) where Rainbow is told the lesson of "Don't knock it until you try it" a lesson that I believe a lot of Bronies hold to dearly for the very show we're watching. And finally Rainbow gets to finish her book and get on with more in the series just chilling at home. (I'd mention a "Reading Rainbow" joke or something about Barking Mad, but I figure that's been said about enough already)
This is a really tough one and I think personally for everyone it's going to come down to which one they enjoyed more personally. As I think both of these are great episodes. And my personal preference, I'm going with Read It and Weep. Sonic Rainboom is one of those instant classics of Season 1 that's for sure up there. But on a personal level, I enjoy Read It and Weep for the Indiana Jones references, getting a little deeper into Dash and Twi's friendship a little bit, and the connections that Bronies can feel for this episode as Rainbow Dash feels insecure about being an Egghead for Reading. As some of might of been of being Fans/Bronies of this very show. Sonic Rainboom was great for all the moments it brought. But I think personally "Don't Knock it until you Try it" is something that's very dear to fans fo this show and ever since getting into it I feel something that everyone on the internet should really understand some times. I feel like this is probably one of those if alot of people still do their own scores and stuff that most are going to pick Sonic Rainboom and that's ok as that's a great one too. But on a personal level I'm giving the edge to Read It and Weep and yet another one for Season 2.
Season 1: 5
Season 2: 11