Most people who say this never even heard Mario talk, I'm willing to bet. They hear him only when he's exclaiming things and they're extrapolating this to a speaking voice when we already have a lot of material of him talking. In general, people who did hear Mario talk like hearing Mario talk.
Like gosh, a guy earlier shared me a video of Charles Martinet narrating a book and the comments section were mostly positive of it.
people need to watch the mario sports mix conference its 10 solid minutes of martinet mario talking and its funny because mario seems to hate puns that arent his own lmao
Counterargument: prolonged exposure to Mario's voice can melt one's ear canal, causing it to drain into the subject's nasal cavity and throat and suffocate them.
What I mean is, I don't think I could personally stand 1h30m to 2h of this:
Like gosh, a guy earlier shared me a video of Charles Martinet narrating a book and the comments section were mostly positive of it.