Luigi's Mansion vs. Luigi's Mansion 2

Which is better?

  • Luigi's Mansion

    Votes: 5 22.7%

  • Luigi's Mansion 2

    Votes: 9 40.9%

  • They're both equally good.

    Votes: 5 22.7%

  • They're both equally bad.

    Votes: 1 4.5%

  • I have no opinion on this.

    Votes: 2 9.1%
  • Total voters
    22
Sonicyay2

Sonicyay2

Monty Mole
Following up on my previous thread, which is better? The GameCube Luigi's Mansion or the 3DS Luigi's Mansion 2(That's Luigi's Mansion: Dark Moon to most of you.)?

Discuss.
 
Probably the only one who thinks this, but LM1 was superior in my opinion.
 
I loved Luigi's Mansion, and it was a very original game, and had a lot of uniqueness to it. Probably one of Nintendo's best Mario games out there.

However, Luigi's Mansion 2 definitely put a lot of nostalgia back into players, and was a very original sequel, and definitely was a lot more comical in a good way. And compared to some of Mario games released lately, this is definitely one that is like a light in a dark room.

So yeah, I put that they are both equally good.
 
cryoAwakening said:
I loved Luigi's Mansion, and it was a very original game, and had a lot of uniqueness to it. Probably one of Nintendo's best Mario games out there.

However, Luigi's Mansion 2 definitely put a lot of nostalgia back into players, and was a very original sequel, and definitely was a lot more comical in a good way. And compared to some of Mario games released lately, this is definitely one that is like a light in a dark room.

So yeah, I put that they are both equally good.
Click to expand...
*claps slowly* great speech.

I liked both games, even though LMDM was longer and harder then the orginal, i still think they are both great. althoug there was something that LMDM lacked that i can't put my finger on.
 
Mega Man said:
cryoAwakening said:
I loved Luigi's Mansion, and it was a very original game, and had a lot of uniqueness to it. Probably one of Nintendo's best Mario games out there.

However, Luigi's Mansion 2 definitely put a lot of nostalgia back into players, and was a very original sequel, and definitely was a lot more comical in a good way. And compared to some of Mario games released lately, this is definitely one that is like a light in a dark room.

So yeah, I put that they are both equally good.
Click to expand...
*claps slowly* great speech.

I liked both games, even though LMDM was longer and harder then the orginal, i still think they are both great. althoug there was something that LMDM lacked that i can't put my finger on.
Click to expand...

I think that it's the ending.

They basically just cut and pasted LM's ending to LMDM and was like "yep, in the end you have to save Mario again from a painting after you defeat King Boo."

I think that was one of the biggest annoyances in the game (That and the fact it bugged me so much with the 4th mansion only having 3 levels instead of 5), but other than that, the game was excellent and really brought the 3DS to enjoyment.
 
Bass said:
Mega Man said:
there was something that LMDM lacked that i can't put my finger on.
Click to expand...
A good soundtrack, maybe?
Click to expand...

The soundtrack was definitely good. I don't know what you're talking about. I really liked the clarinet, and I thought it was a good transition between new themes and old LM themes.
 
Aside from the songs that were remixed from the first one, I found most of Dark Moon's soundtrack, especially the boss themes, to be very bland, boring, and unmemorable. The only boss theme, in my opinion, that came even remotely close to being good was King Boo's theme, and even that was far more fitting for a cutscene than an actual boss fight.
 
Bass said:
Aside from the songs that were remixed from the first one, I found most of Dark Moon's soundtrack, especially the boss themes, to be very bland, boring, and unmemorable. The only boss theme, in my opinion, that came even remotely close to being good was King Boo's theme, and even that was far more fitting for a cutscene than an actual boss fight.
Click to expand...
Like I said before, no offense, but you have extremely high standards for games.

Personally I liked LMDM better.
 
Mr. Game & Watch said:
Bass said:
Aside from the songs that were remixed from the first one, I found most of Dark Moon's soundtrack, especially the boss themes, to be very bland, boring, and unmemorable. The only boss theme, in my opinion, that came even remotely close to being good was King Boo's theme, and even that was far more fitting for a cutscene than an actual boss fight.
Click to expand...
Like I said before, no offense, but you have extremely high standards for games.

Personally I liked LMDM better.
Click to expand...
Unlike I said before, I kinda disagree to this. I kinda thought the soundtrack was a bit bland like.....I'm gonna assume it's a robot so....it.(I kid, I kid! I went on his profile and now I know he's male! Geez.)