Rating boards are unnecessary

Should we get rid of rating boards and make companies rate their games themselves?

  • I strongly agree

    Votes: 2 11.1%
  • I agree

    Votes: 2 11.1%
  • I disagree

    Votes: 3 16.7%
  • I strongly disagree

    Votes: 11 61.1%

  • Total voters
    18
Crazy Dave said:
Seriously, why the living hell did Kirby's Return to Dreamland get an E10+!?
Kirby is darker than you think.

Because Kirby refuses to wear pants?
 
Actually, I don't see why a company would falsely rate their game just to make it sell. Falsely rating a game won't make it sell. In fact, it would be false advertising which is illegal.

Also, that stuff you are saying about dream land is exactly what I mean. None of the rating boards around the world are accurate at all so why have them at all? It's like saying that you should keep a student in your class even though they are not acting right nor are they keeping good grades (F average students). I don't think a company will lie about their game to make it sell well mostly because it won't. Do you honestly think that Rockstar games would falsely rate GTA at an E rating or EC rating? To be honest I have seen the ESRB lie about content that is in a game themselves. Again, I think companies will be more honest and accurate about their games since they know their target audience, content and everything.
 
If a company has a game typically rated "M", but they are targeting a teenage market, they'd be stupid not to rate it "T".

Conversely, a relatively harmless "E" game might be bumped up the scale to attract older audiences.
 
chillv said:
Actually, I don't see why a company would falsely rate their game just to make it sell. Falsely rating a game won't make it sell. In fact, it would be false advertising which is illegal.
It's illegal, but that doesn't stop people from doing it.
 
Crazy Dave said:
chillv said:
Actually, I don't see why a company would falsely rate their game just to make it sell. Falsely rating a game won't make it sell. In fact, it would be false advertising which is illegal.
It's illegal, but that doesn't stop people from doing it.
Have video game companies ever done it though?
 
chillv said:
Crazy Dave said:
chillv said:
Actually, I don't see why a company would falsely rate their game just to make it sell. Falsely rating a game won't make it sell. In fact, it would be false advertising which is illegal.
It's illegal, but that doesn't stop people from doing it.
Have video game companies ever done it though?
False advertisement? Sure. Bending the ratings? Of course, companies will do whatever they can to get that certain rating that guarantees maximun sales, removing content, modifying it, etc. If your idea came though, it would just destroy whatever credibility ratings for games have, meaning soccer moms and politicians would start to complain again.
 
chillv said:
Crazy Dave said:
chillv said:
Actually, I don't see why a company would falsely rate their game just to make it sell. Falsely rating a game won't make it sell. In fact, it would be false advertising which is illegal.
It's illegal, but that doesn't stop people from doing it.
Have video game companies ever done it though?
No, because ESRB rates games.
 
Crazy Dave said:
chillv said:
Crazy Dave said:
chillv said:
Actually, I don't see why a company would falsely rat