What do you think could have been done to prevent the Shootings at Sandy Hook?

What do you think could have been done to prevent the Shootings in Sandy Hook Elm.?

  • Restrictions of Assault Guns

    Votes: 21 63.6%
  • Improved school secutity

    Votes: 7 21.2%
  • More frequent insanity tests

    Votes: 1 3.0%
  • More freedom of guns to the teachers

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Children having more Self-Defense training

    Votes: 4 12.1%

  • Total voters
    33
what's there to say? i already said i was in favor of more regulation, right?

but on the other hand if we have more people who are licensed to kill carry firearms, wouldn't there be a lower crime rate?

I'm looking at Germany, who has one of the lowest homicide rates worldwide. But their guns are still available, just harder to get. It's still possible for any citizen to carry around their weapon, though, which is why I don't understand the logic of preventing concealed carry.

Also, the regulation still doesn't stop truly determined shooters in Germany.
 
Thank Christ you finally responded, I've been trying to get you and Banjo's attention for yonks now. Given that Germany still has some pretty harsh regulation on gun ownership, it seem we're thankfully both in agreement; the current state of gun politics in America is stupidly archaic and too fixated on self-defense and responsive measures, rather than preventative measures to reduce the chances of these disasters happening in the first place (the obvious tighter gun control and better mental health care options, first and foremost), and that desperately needs to change ASAP.
 
Dr. Javelin said:
whoa there

Just because I was taking your post in a humorous way doesn't mean I'm being antagonistic. Or at least not intentionally. Am I?
I didn't take it as antagonistic, I took it as you not taking the argument seriously. I don't think it helped that you ignored the rest of my points by providing a single possible exception.

Dr. Javelin said:
And personally, I'd rather do something than simply run away. Living with the guilt that I might have done something for the rest of my life would be horrible. You might be different, and that's fine - I'm just saying that I'm willing to risk or sacrifice my life for that of others - which in your scenario would be those who are still pinned down my the shooter.
At this point in my life, I'd be willing to sacrifice myself to save the lives of others. I'm only 20, have no wife or family (aside from my two parents who I think could take care of themselves), haven't really done anything productive with my life... I have nothing to lose, my family doesn't have much to lose, and the captives have everything to gain.

But if I were a single parent, if I had a family to support and my wife was disabled (i.e unable to provide for the family), or even if I had a pregnant wife/girlfriend, I would prioritize my responsibility to them over others. Maybe that makes me a bad person. But would I just outright abandon the people trapped? No. Some would, and I think it's a reasonable reaction, but I would -- at the very least -- call the authorities.

Honestly, I don't think I could bring myself to leave the scene without knowing the captives were safe or that the cops/FBI were there to do their job. But that doesn't mean I'm going to risk my life in hopes of taking down the gunman, if I have people who depend on me[specifically] on a daily basis.

Dr. Javelin said:
And about how he took down the trained security guard and how I wouldn't be able to take him out? It's all about something called element of surprise. Training isn't worth anything if you aren't expecting anything to happen, and a guard can't remain on high alert for all eternity. Neither can the gunman.
I suppose that's a fair point, but the element of surprise doesn't last for all eternity either. The gunman is going to find out you're there, whether it's by hearing/seeing you himself, or even from one of the captives indicating that they saw you (sudden change in a person's body language would be hard to ignore unless the gunman simply wasn't paying attention). You'd have to act quickly and hope that the surroundings don't put you at a disadvantage. (Again, like with the shooter being near a crowd or just a single person.)

If I had the benefit of knowing that the gunman was unaware of my location or that I was even there, I would personally be trying to find a safe way for the captives to escape (fire exit, back door, basement/garage, alternate passage, I think you get the idea) without the gunman noticing. But note that I would only do so if the situation allowed for it to be done without the captives getting hurt -- this obviously isn't going to work in small locations, but it would in larger ones where the gunman can't keep an eye on everything. To me, it seems about as likely to work as your scenario where you can pop off a shot and take down the gunman with no one else getting hurt in the process.

But all of this is based on ifs and variables, and is starting to turn into a Gun Control 2.0 thread. I digress.
 
I don't have any problem with doing more to prevent convicted criminals or the mentally ill from acquiring a firearm (as long as it does not restrict law-abiding citizens from exercising their Constitutional right, which is difficult to do). The reasoning behind my suggestion was that it usually takes more than legislation to stop a person who's determined to commit a heinous act (such as this one), and it helps to be prepared.
 
Crocodile Dippy said:
Thank Christ you finally responded, I've been trying to get you and Banjo's attention for yonks now.
it's nice to know you guys apparently consider us serious enough to remember us by name >_>
 
Dr. Javelin said:
I'm just saying that I'm willing to risk or sacrifice my life for that of others

no

you're willing to claim you're willing to do those things

on the internet

are you dealing with life threatening situations on a daily basis?? if not, you don't know how you'd actually respond to one
 
That's actually a fair point that I'm guilty of too



But I've been around gunfire before, so I'm certain I'd at least have the composure to call the police for help.
 
Dr. Javelin said:
it's nice to know you guys apparently consider us serious enough to remember us by name >_>
My logic was that if I mention it enough, I'd annoy you blokes into responding.
 
Bulbasaur said:
Dr. Javelin said:
I'm just saying that I'm willing to risk or sacrifice my life for that of others

no

you're willing to claim you're willing to do those things

on the internet

are you dealing with life threatening situations on a daily basis?? if not, you don't know how you'd actually respond to one

Doesn't mean he won't do it out of reaction either, however.
 
Bulbasaur said:
Dr. Javelin said:
I'm just saying that I'm willing to risk or sacrifice my life for that of others
no

you're willing to claim you're willing to do those things

on the internet

are you dealing with life threatening situations on a daily basis?? if not, you don't know how you'd actually respond to one
are you dealing with life threatening situations on a daily basis??

Also, I've seriously considered (and I still might) going into the military, which is exactly what I'm talking about with risk and sacrifice.