Sonic Heroes is pretty much the turning point for how characters are arranged in the Modern Sonic branch of the Sonic the Hedgehog franchise. It decided teams consist of three characters, it decided characters are divided into Speed, Flight, and Power types, and it decided a conventional team has one character of each type. It also decided which characters go on what teams, placements that have defined the supporting cast for each character for years to come. Sonic Heroes invented Cream the Rabbit to be Amy Rose's sidekick, and appended the mostly unmoored Big the Cat to that team. (In case you were wondering, Cream was actually planted in Sonic Advance 2 to get her to make appearances in games earlier than Sonic Heroes.) Shadow the Hedgehog and Rouge the Bat were a pair in Sonic Adventure 2, but Team Dark cemented it and added E-123 Omega to complete the set. In the original Japanese story, the Chaotix were the set of five unlinked characters, Knuckles, Espio, Charmy, Vector, and Mighty, who happen to all share a game in Knuckles' Chaotix. In the Western decanonized story, the Chaotix were all characters who were Knuckles' friends, and tie in media made them an actual team. Sonic Heroes redefined the set as a true blue grouping as Team Chaotix, dropping Mighty and Knuckles. Mighty the Armadillo would languish in obscurity before being revisited as a Classic Sonic exclusive character. Knuckles the Echidna, on the other hand, would become the third member of Team Sonic, joining Sonic and Tails and cementing his position as "Heroic Main Character #3". Sonic Heroes marked the first major time Knuckles joined Sonic the Hedgehog and Miles "Tails" Prower in a Sonic the Hedgehog story for no reason other than to help the duo stop Dr. Eggman. Nearly all prior stories made Sonic and Knuckles team ups a matter of circumstance, with the exception of the extremely inconsequential Western decanonized story for Sonic Blast. There's always been a little flux regarding the teams created by Sonic Heroes, but they tend to default back to their Sonic Heroes arrangement in the long term. Team Sonic espicially is set in stone, meaning Sonic, Tails, and Knuckles appear together in nearly every game all three of them are in.
These arrangements have done weird things to certain characters. Most obvious is Knuckles. He is supposed to always be on Angel Island to guard the Master Emerald, rarely ever leaving. If he does, it is usually for reasons related to people tampering with mystical energy like those of the Chaos Emeralds or the Master Emerald, and sometimes his only reason for leaving is to recover the Master Emerald if it is stolen or to recover the pieces of the Master Emerald if it is broken. And sometimes Eggman tricks him into thinking Sonic is trying to steal the Master Emerald so he has to fight Sonic. But as he is a member of Team Sonic and Team Sonic's motivation is generically protecting the world from evil or goofing around, so Knuckles is often in random games that his motivation dictates he shouldn't be in. There's no reason for Knuckles to be present in Sonic Riders: Zero Gravity and Sonic Free Riders from the start of those games, given that nothing "emeraldy" or mystical is happening at the start of the game, but he's a member of Team Sonic so he has to be. (Sonic Riders: Zero Gravity gets mystical pretty quickly, but Knuckles is present before that becomes evident.) This also results in weird inconsistencies in tie in media like the IDW comics, where the staff have a hard time getting permission to use Knuckles in stories because SEGA believes the character would not leave Angel Island except under dire circumstances, yet he shows up regularly in Team Sonic in SEGA video games that are not about dire circumstances. Its worse for Amy Rose. Prior to Sonic Heroes, she was basically "Heroic Main Character #4", showing up wherever Sonic went. However, Sonic Heroes put Amy on Team Rose, and it needed to come up with a reason to justify Team Sonic and Team Rose fighting each other because all 2000s Sonic games with multiple playable characters had to have them throw hands. Thus, Sonic Heroes flanderized Amy's love of Sonic into outright mania and an inclination to aggression when she doesn't get her way. This would stick all the way up until the late 2010s, which ratcheted down Amy's love of Sonic into more of a strong but secretive crush. This is more consistent with her original portrayals and it is more in line with modern opinions on romance and female characters, but the character of Amy should not have been stretched to make her insane in certain situations at all. It only happened because of Sonic Heroes.
Sonic Heroes's character roster had a lot of flux before landed on the four teams in the final game. There were pitches for Mighty and Ray to return in it, a concept for. girl team that consisted of Amy, Cream, and Rouge, and even having playable villains. But what the the dice fell a little differently when Sonic Heroes was being finalized? What if Knuckles was a member of Team Chaotix, and what if Amy was a member of Team Sonic?
For this hypothetical, I want to change as little about Sonic Heroes as possible. So its still a story where the four teams each learn Dr. Eggman is up to something and set out to stop him, and wind up fighting each other along the way. At the end, they learn that Metal Sonic imprisoned the real Eggman and is pretending to be him in a plot to copy data from most of the teams in order to achieve ultimate power and defeat Sonic the Hedgehog. That means the concept for a villains team is still off the table. Also, the game still needs to have Shadow in it in order to meet fan demand and it can still only have four teams. Thus, I think the roster ends up the following:
Team Explorers replaces Team Rose as the easy mode of the game. Narrative wise, the chracters would all have just met, with Big's pet Froggy being missing being the team's primary motivation. The other two characters are here to help Big. Amy's Propeller Hammer from the released Sonic Heroes, which gave her a limited hover, would be reinterpeted as a form of Ray's gliding. I do not entirely believe Team Chaotix in this version of the story would be detectives. I think they would be treasure hunters, matching Knuckles's stated profession, and they find a lead for treasure that happens to get them involved in Dr. Eggman's evil scheme. Cream the Rabbit would not exist in this version of the franchise, as she was created to be a sidekick for Amy and this arrangement does not need a sidekick for Amy. Vector the Crocodile joins Mighty the Armadillo in being lost to obscurity until Sonic Mania revives them as characters in the Classic Sonic branch of the franchise.
I think this arrangement of characters leads to a final game that still closely resembles the Sonic Heroes we know, but puts Knuckles and Amy into less perilous spots for their characters. Without being a part of Team Sonic, Knuckles can be consistently aloof as his character is supposed to be. Team Chaotix wouldn't necessarily have to appear together in every game. Much like the Team Chaotix of this world, this alternate Team Chaotix could still use Knuckles and Espio separately from the team or have Knuckles lead a different Team Chaotix when the stituation calls for it. It would also be less jarring for Western audiences compared to the Team Chaotix of Sonic Heroes, as it keeps the lead chracter of Knuckles' Chaotix in the set. Meanwhile, since Amy would be part of Team Sonic, her character doesn't have to get more extreme to justify her fighting Sonic. Since Amy is already "Heroic Main Character #4" and her motivation is just to be around Sonic as much as possible, having Amy be in lots of games alongside like Knuckles is in the real world does not disrupt her fictional motivations. Thus, they can stay completely consistent even in licensed media like the IDW comics. What do you guys think of this alternate version of the Sonic Heroes teams?
These arrangements have done weird things to certain characters. Most obvious is Knuckles. He is supposed to always be on Angel Island to guard the Master Emerald, rarely ever leaving. If he does, it is usually for reasons related to people tampering with mystical energy like those of the Chaos Emeralds or the Master Emerald, and sometimes his only reason for leaving is to recover the Master Emerald if it is stolen or to recover the pieces of the Master Emerald if it is broken. And sometimes Eggman tricks him into thinking Sonic is trying to steal the Master Emerald so he has to fight Sonic. But as he is a member of Team Sonic and Team Sonic's motivation is generically protecting the world from evil or goofing around, so Knuckles is often in random games that his motivation dictates he shouldn't be in. There's no reason for Knuckles to be present in Sonic Riders: Zero Gravity and Sonic Free Riders from the start of those games, given that nothing "emeraldy" or mystical is happening at the start of the game, but he's a member of Team Sonic so he has to be. (Sonic Riders: Zero Gravity gets mystical pretty quickly, but Knuckles is present before that becomes evident.) This also results in weird inconsistencies in tie in media like the IDW comics, where the staff have a hard time getting permission to use Knuckles in stories because SEGA believes the character would not leave Angel Island except under dire circumstances, yet he shows up regularly in Team Sonic in SEGA video games that are not about dire circumstances. Its worse for Amy Rose. Prior to Sonic Heroes, she was basically "Heroic Main Character #4", showing up wherever Sonic went. However, Sonic Heroes put Amy on Team Rose, and it needed to come up with a reason to justify Team Sonic and Team Rose fighting each other because all 2000s Sonic games with multiple playable characters had to have them throw hands. Thus, Sonic Heroes flanderized Amy's love of Sonic into outright mania and an inclination to aggression when she doesn't get her way. This would stick all the way up until the late 2010s, which ratcheted down Amy's love of Sonic into more of a strong but secretive crush. This is more consistent with her original portrayals and it is more in line with modern opinions on romance and female characters, but the character of Amy should not have been stretched to make her insane in certain situations at all. It only happened because of Sonic Heroes.
Sonic Heroes's character roster had a lot of flux before landed on the four teams in the final game. There were pitches for Mighty and Ray to return in it, a concept for. girl team that consisted of Amy, Cream, and Rouge, and even having playable villains. But what the the dice fell a little differently when Sonic Heroes was being finalized? What if Knuckles was a member of Team Chaotix, and what if Amy was a member of Team Sonic?
For this hypothetical, I want to change as little about Sonic Heroes as possible. So its still a story where the four teams each learn Dr. Eggman is up to something and set out to stop him, and wind up fighting each other along the way. At the end, they learn that Metal Sonic imprisoned the real Eggman and is pretending to be him in a plot to copy data from most of the teams in order to achieve ultimate power and defeat Sonic the Hedgehog. That means the concept for a villains team is still off the table. Also, the game still needs to have Shadow in it in order to meet fan demand and it can still only have four teams. Thus, I think the roster ends up the following:
| Speed | Flight | Power | |
| Team Sonic | Sonic | Tails | Amy |
| Team Dark | Shadow | Rouge | Omega |
| Team Explorers | Ray | Original Character | Big |
| Team Chaotix | Espio | Charmy | Knuckles |
Team Explorers replaces Team Rose as the easy mode of the game. Narrative wise, the chracters would all have just met, with Big's pet Froggy being missing being the team's primary motivation. The other two characters are here to help Big. Amy's Propeller Hammer from the released Sonic Heroes, which gave her a limited hover, would be reinterpeted as a form of Ray's gliding. I do not entirely believe Team Chaotix in this version of the story would be detectives. I think they would be treasure hunters, matching Knuckles's stated profession, and they find a lead for treasure that happens to get them involved in Dr. Eggman's evil scheme. Cream the Rabbit would not exist in this version of the franchise, as she was created to be a sidekick for Amy and this arrangement does not need a sidekick for Amy. Vector the Crocodile joins Mighty the Armadillo in being lost to obscurity until Sonic Mania revives them as characters in the Classic Sonic branch of the franchise.
I think this arrangement of characters leads to a final game that still closely resembles the Sonic Heroes we know, but puts Knuckles and Amy into less perilous spots for their characters. Without being a part of Team Sonic, Knuckles can be consistently aloof as his character is supposed to be. Team Chaotix wouldn't necessarily have to appear together in every game. Much like the Team Chaotix of this world, this alternate Team Chaotix could still use Knuckles and Espio separately from the team or have Knuckles lead a different Team Chaotix when the stituation calls for it. It would also be less jarring for Western audiences compared to the Team Chaotix of Sonic Heroes, as it keeps the lead chracter of Knuckles' Chaotix in the set. Meanwhile, since Amy would be part of Team Sonic, her character doesn't have to get more extreme to justify her fighting Sonic. Since Amy is already "Heroic Main Character #4" and her motivation is just to be around Sonic as much as possible, having Amy be in lots of games alongside like Knuckles is in the real world does not disrupt her fictional motivations. Thus, they can stay completely consistent even in licensed media like the IDW comics. What do you guys think of this alternate version of the Sonic Heroes teams?