Project: Banners

TPG

from deltarune
Awards Committee
'Shroom Consultant
Poll Consultant
Pronouns
He/Him/His
I figured that since we seem to be redoing all of the wiki banners, the project deserves its own thread.

So in case you were wondering, the general understanding is that the banners that appear on some of our MarioWiki:__ pages are outdated; they're edgy, haven't aged well and are poorly put together. I think this old one represents everything wrong with 'em- the creator dumped some artworks onto a document, ran some random filters through them (making them look ugly and unidentifiable), and slapped some generic font "The 'Shroom" onto it.

I made a critique of the ones I could find here, and so far we've added a new banner for the Poll page, designed one for the Maintenance page, drafted a proposals one, and discussed a Featured Articles one.

List of banners in order of progress:

Poll Banner: Created, on the wiki, completed project.

Maintenance banner: Created, on the wiki, completed project.

Proposals banner: Created, on the wiki, completed project.

Featured articles banner: Created, on the wiki, completed project.

'Shroom banners (1, 2) will have to be ignored since its not our problem; its something that the 'Shroom Staff will deal with, not us.

So first things first, I think that the new maintenance banner is ready to be uploaded! However, I'd like to get confirmation from the wiki staff before going ahead and uploading it.

If that shoddy list up there is missing anything, tell me and I'll add it in.
 
The new maintenance banner is looking good. As a last-minute suggestion, maybe it would look a little better without that girder being cut off at the very top. I did a quick edit to remove it, but which do you think is better? I think it looks a lot cleaner and simpler without it.
 
Yeah, I agree. I altered it a little though- here. The ladders looked a bit choppy since they had nothing to attach to, so I built the ladders up so they reached the top (and for the left ladder's case, I broke the middle up since some of the ladders in Donkey Kong had that going on).

So for reference:

maintenanceFull.png
JngQNP0.png
cZ2Aqca.png
 
Fantastic.

We should just allow a little time in case others had some further input. Otherwise, it looks like your overall design has already gained general support: I'd suggest re-uploading directly over File:Maintenance.png.
 
It's bothering me (more than it should, tbh) that Luigi and Bowser are just floating on nothing while Mario is tucked nicely in the "C". I tried messing around with the banner myself, but the sprites are too big to fit in the other letter gaps (the top half of the "A", the rungs of the "E") without cutting them off.
 
I think it's alright, the sprites do line up with the bottom of the letters to a pixel perfect level, but maybe adding a shadow beneath them would work?
 
I've done above two changes again in my version as I have everything layered and could avoid those artefacts from the bridge behind the Fire Flower.

maintenanceFull.1.1.png

I've done two shots at the shadow thing too, separately.

maintenanceFull.1.2.png


maintenanceFull.1.3.png

Also, I'me working on a thing for Proposals too, will post soon(ish).
 
I like them shadows: the latter of the two banners (with a slightly wider Bowser shadow) works better in my opinion.
 
Shokora said:
I like them shadows: the latter of the two banners (with a slightly wider Bowser shadow) works better in my opinion.
Per.
 
Btw, looking at the image formatting for the maintenance page:
Code:
[[File:Maintenance.png|center]]

Uploading the new banner (which is 1,600 pixels wide) would make the banner extend past the page border, so could a wiki staff member add the '|800px|' tag onto the image like this:
Code:
[[File:Maintenance.png|800px|center]]

Doing that should fix any issues with sizing.