so i wrote this thing

IcicleRain

best ice user
it's not a fanfic or userfic and it's really rather personal but I just wanted to post it and get some feedback
It all starts on the first day.
Of course it does, that’s what first days are for, new beginnings and clean breaks and fresh starts.
She’s standing at the edge of the room, knowing nobody, hand pushed against the walls, when she sees her.
She’s the brightest light in the hall, talking to the terrifyingly tall girls and laughing and she’s everything the other girl wants.
But that’s not really when it starts.

It starts again a few months later, when it’s January to the start in September.
The dull dreariness of geography class next to Laura, fun, sociable Laura who’s probably more trouble than she’s worth but she’s something-not liked, not really, but solid.
Stable.
“Sorry, can I sit here?”
But that’s still not really when it starts.

It really starts even more months later, when she’s sitting there, bored on Saturday in the middle of July with no school to worry about, no forced socialising.
It hits her- this is love.
But is that really start?

Too soon, it’s September-which is a good month for starts.
They aren’t really friends yet but she sits as close to her as she can without seeming needy.
She feigns interest in talk about drums and rock bands and struggles to get to safer ground, the video games and comic books she knows.
It’s nice, and it stays nice.
But it’s not enough to really call a start.

Then it’s December, Christmas and snow and really when you start to feel that school is almost done and it’s the holidays.
The Christmas concert.
She was too nervous to say yes, even when Mr Kerr had insisted her violin should be played.
But she’s up there, playing her drums with her band.
All she can do is watch.
And it really might be a start.

Things don’t change until the next year.
September, 2014- September gets mentioned a lot here, doesn’t it?
They get all the seats together.
Are the teachers trying to tell them something or is it just blind luck they get the seats each time?
Laura is long gone from geography now, and they sit and laugh and chat to the teacher.
It’s not enough for her, but it’s all she’s able to manage.
It really is close to the start.

Then it’s Christmas again, the exams long ago finished with.
The concert again.
She still didn’t say yes.
But she’s there. Not just playing the drums, but she’s singing.
It’s too loud to make out the lyrics but her voice is there.
And then she comes back off stage and stands next to her.
And really, she almost starts it.

The mock exams.
Terrifying for some, but she doesn’t have a problem.
She’s calm and cool and collected.
She comes over at lunch and they laugh about the exams and she pretends to be worried about how she did to seem normal.
The cover probably doesn’t work but she tries.
Then on Friday they’re laughing about drawings and maths and suddenly they’re alone in the form room, everyone else finished with their lockers long ago.
And mother is outside and she should go but-
But she doesn’t want to.
She really doesn’t want to, but she can’t start it.


And sometimes it feels like she really never will.
 
Really good. I've totally been there too, and you capture the experience well.

Specific writing glitches (dunno what kind of feedback you want, so I'll just do what I've done for others):

"when it’s January to the start in September." - unclear
"next to Laura, fun" - either a period or a dash would probably be better here than a mere comma
"something-not" - I'd suggest putting spaces between the dash and the words so that it doesn't look like a hyphen (same with other dashes, although it only tripped me up with the comprehension here)
"even more months later" - since you say the month's name you could probably just go with "much later": less of a mouthful, less repetition
"that really start?" - "the start"
"safer ground," - comma splice again: a dash or colon would be better imo
"September, 2014- September gets mentioned a lot here, doesn’t it?" - bit of an oddball line, between the specific date and the conversational aside, although I do think it's good to point out how September really does come up a lot
"Laura is long gone from geography now, and they sit and laugh and chat to the teacher." - a bit confusing: if she's not in the class, why is she still there? Although I think the fact that they don't share the class it all started in is a good detail to include; the second half just needs a bit of clarification ("in the other classes, they sit...", "but she still comes around ad they sit..." etc.)
"the exams long ago finished with." - sounds a but jumbled: I'd suggest swapping in "since" for "ago", and perhaps reconsider ending it in "with"
"really never will." - drop the "really" from the last line: more punchy, less repetitive with the penultimate line, and it doesn't need the extra emphasis anyway.

But yeah, little grammar/punctuation things aside, it's great. Really nails the feeling of wanting someone, but being too scared to do anything, and just taking what little scraps of friendship you can get as the months and years slip by. When you feel hopeless, but at the same time, can't give up on the feelings...

At least, that's what I got out of what you wrote - but for all I know, I'm just projecting or something. Either way, I quite liked it.
 
whoa

this is indeed a thing
Walkazo said:
At least, that's what I got out of what you wrote - but for all I know, I'm just projecting or something.
:???:
 
A disclaimer, in case my interpretation on the exact feelings conveyed in the piece are way off due to being coloured by my memories of my own similar experiences.
 
Back