I'd love a lot of these, but I voted for "Conventions emphasizing sharing creative works" because let's be real, most of the others would probably still limit themselves to the most mainstream parts of the Mario franchise and I want a place where I can just go and openly show my love for the...
I mean other characters have been shrunk to fit the gameplay of Mario Kart (Honey Queen being the most notable example outside of Bowser, whose size varies anyway)
I don't think crazy world ending villains like Shadow Queen should be written off either. Them racing around with Toad and Goomba would be funny (and appeal to people who like that type of character in the series) and I don't think any further reason is needed.
Veterans
1. Mario
2. Luigi
3. Peach
4. Bowser
5. Bowser Jr.
6. Daisy
7. Rosalina
8. Pauline
9. Wario
10. Waluigi
11. Yoshi
12. Toad
13. Toadette
14. King Boo
15. Petey Piranha
16. Baby Mario
17. Baby Luigi
18. Baby Peach
19. Birdo
20. Donkey Kong
21. Diddy Kong
22. Funky Kong
23. Dixie Kong
24...
On the contrary I find it mediocre at *worst,* and people grossly overexaggerate its negatives while downplaying its positives. It does a lot more right than wrong in my opinion. There is not enough appreciation for all the things that SPM was the last game to have, everyone always only looks at...
I don't understand the notion that the enemy/species inclusions are worse than the babies and metals. Their designs are wholly their own, not iterative on that of another character already on the roster. That alone gives them more merit than Pink Gold Peach, Baby Daisy/Rosalina, and Tanooki...
Out of these, I'd pair Waluigi with Rosalina, Prince Haru with Spike, and Mona with Mary O.
I thought about commenting earlier but I didn't quite know how to express how i felt about the way this is structured. Eventually decided to just make two of my picks intentionally go against that structure.
It's hard for me to define a single favorite year, but contenders are
2007- Super Paper Mario is my favorite game of all time, Super Mario Galaxy is peak & still a contender for my favorite 3D Mario, Mario Party 8 & DS were the last hurrah of Hudson's Mario Party and the last traditionally...