Hurt and Heal: Runner-up Edition (vol.4)

Actually your post was 48, which means you use the next item

Cole McGrath: 14
Nathan Drake: 15
Ganondorf: 15
Saria: 12
Zero Suit Samus: 15
Knuckles the Echindna: 15
Bowser Jr.: 16
Maylene: 15
Misty: 15
Leon Powalski: 15
Kirby & the Amazing Mirror: 15
Fluttershy: 16
Starlow: 12
Pianta: 16
Ned's Declassified School Survival Guide: 18
Dr. Neo Cortex: 15
Meta Knight: 16
Toad: 15
Football Zombie: 16
Rarity: 16
Rouge the Bat: 15
Chandelure: 16
Sheik: 15
Skull Kid: 15
Spike: 16
Luigi: 15

Dead as a doornail
Wattson
Whittle
Danny
Pigma Dengar
Ray the Flying Squirrel

Post count: 49
 
you miscounted actually. but if you don't want to use an item i'll use it.

Cole McGrath: 14
Nathan Drake: 15
Ganondorf: 15
Saria: 12
Zero Suit Samus: 15
Knuckles the Echindna: 15
Bowser Jr.: 16
Maylene: 15
Misty: 15
Leon Powalski: 15
Kirby & the Amazing Mirror: 15
Fluttershy: 16
Starlow: 10
Pianta: 16
Ned's Declassified School Survival Guide: 18
Dr. Neo Cortex: 15
Meta Knight: 16
Toad: 15
Football Zombie: 16
Rarity: 16
Rouge the Bat: 15
Chandelure: 16
Sheik: 15
Skull Kid: 15
Spike: 16
Luigi: 15

Dead as a doornail
Wattson
Whittle
Danny
Pigma Dengar
Ray the Flying Squirrel

Post count: 51
 
OK.

Cole McGrath: 14
Nathan Drake: 15
Ganondorf: 15
Saria: 12
Zero Suit Samus: 15
Knuckles the Echindna: 15
Bowser Jr.: 16
Maylene: 15
Misty: 15
Leon Powalski: 15
Kirby & the Amazing Mirror: 15
Fluttershy: 16
Starlow: 8
Pianta: 16
Ned's Declassified School Survival Guide: 18
Dr. Neo Cortex: 15
Meta Knight: 16
Toad: 15
Football Zombie: 16
Rarity: 16
Rouge the Bat: 15
Chandelure: 16
Sheik: 15
Skull Kid: 15
Spike: 16
Luigi: 15

Dead as a doornail
Wattson
Whittle
Danny
Pigma Dengar
Ray the Flying Squirrel

Post count: 52
 
(if you don't want to use an item, the next person is allowed to use one)

Since you declined, i'll use uka uka on Rarity.

Cole McGrath: 14
Nathan Drake: 15
Ganondorf: 15
Saria: 12
Zero Suit Samus: 15
Knuckles the Echindna: 15
Bowser Jr.: 16
Maylene: 15
Misty: 15
Leon Powalski: 15
Kirby & the Amazing Mirror: 15
Fluttershy: 16
Starlow: 8
Pianta: 16
Ned's Declassified School Survival Guide: 18
Dr. Neo Cortex: 15
Meta Knight: 16
Toad: 15
Football Zombie: 16
Rarity: 16*10
Rouge the Bat: 15
Chandelure: 16
Sheik: 15
Skull Kid: 15
Spike: 16
Luigi: 15

Dead as a doornail
Wattson
Whittle
Danny
Pigma Dengar
Ray the Flying Squirrel

Post count: 53
 
Cole McGrath: 14
Nathan Drake: 15
Ganondorf: 15
Saria: 12
Zero Suit Samus: 15
Knuckles the Echindna: 15
Bowser Jr.: 16
Maylene: 15
Misty: 15
Leon Powalski: 15
Kirby & the Amazing Mirror: 15
Fluttershy: 16
Starlow: 6
Pianta: 16
Ned's Declassified School Survival Guide: 18
Dr. Neo Cortex: 15
Meta Knight: 16
Toad: 15
Football Zombie: 16
Rarity: 16*9
Rouge the Bat: 15
Chandelure: 16
Sheik: 15
Skull Kid: 15
Spike: 16
Luigi: 15

Dead as a doornail
Wattson
Whittle
Danny
Pigma Dengar
Ray the Flying Squirrel

Post count: 53
 
Cole McGrath: 14
Nathan Drake: 15
Ganondorf: 15
Saria: 12
Zero Suit Samus: 15
Knuckles the Echindna: 15
Bowser Jr.: 16
Maylene: 15
Misty: 15
Leon Powalski: 15
Kirby & the Amazing Mirror: 15
Fluttershy: 16
Starlow: 4
Pianta: 16
Ned's Declassified School Survival Guide: 18
Dr. Neo Cortex: 15
Meta Knight: 16
Toad: 15
Football Zombie: 16
Rarity: 16*8
Rouge the Bat: 15
Chandelure: 16
Sheik: 15
Skull Kid: 15
Spike: 16
Luigi: 15

Dead as a doornail
Wattson
Whittle
Danny
Pigma Dengar
Ray the Flying Squirrel

Post count: 55
 
Cole McGrath: 14
Nathan Drake: 15
Ganondorf: 15
Saria: 12
Zero Suit Samus: 15
Knuckles the Echindna: 15
Bowser Jr.: 16
Maylene: 15
Misty: 15
Leon Powalski: 15
Kirby & the Amazing Mirror: 15
Fluttershy: 16
Starlow: 2
Pianta: 16
Ned's Declassified School Survival Guide: 18
Dr. Neo Cortex: 15
Meta Knight: 16
Toad: 15
Football Zombie: 16
Rarity: 16*8
Rouge the Bat: 15
Chandelure: 16
Sheik: 15
Skull Kid: 15
Spike: 16
Luigi: 15

Dead as a doornail
Wattson
Whittle
Danny
Pigma Dengar
Ray the Flying Squirrel

Post count: 56
 
Cole McGrath: 14
Nathan Drake: 15
Ganondorf: 15
Saria: 12
Zero Suit Samus: 15
Knuckles the Echindna: 15
Bowser Jr.: 16
Maylene: 15
Misty: 15
Leon Powalski: 15
Kirby & the Amazing Mirror: 15
Fluttershy: 16
Pianta: 16
Ned's Declassified School Survival Guide: 18
Dr. Neo Cortex: 15
Meta Knight: 16
Toad: 15
Football Zombie: 16
Rarity: 16*6
Rouge the Bat: 15
Chandelure: 16
Sheik: 15
Skull Kid: 15
Spike: 16
Luigi: 15

Dead as a doornail
Wattson
Whittle
Danny
Pigma Dengar
Ray the Flying Squirrel
Starlow

Post count: 57
 
Cole McGrath: 14
Nathan Drake: 15
Ganondorf: 15
Saria: 12
Zero Suit Samus: 15
Knuckles the Echindna: 15
Bowser Jr.: 16
Maylene: 15
Misty: 13
Leon Powalski: 15
Kirby & the Amazing Mirror: 15
Fluttershy: 16
Pianta: 16
Ned's Declassified School Survival Guide: 18
Dr. Neo Cortex: 15
Meta Knight: 16
Toad: 15
Football Zombie: 16
Rarity: 16*6
Rouge the Bat: 15
Chandelure: 16
Sheik: 15
Skull Kid: 15
Spike: 16
Luigi: 15

Dead as a doornail
Wattson
Whittle
Danny
Pigma Dengar
Ray the Flying Squirrel
Starlow

Post count: 58
 
Cole McGrath: 14
Nathan Drake: 15
Ganondorf: 15
Saria: 12
Zero Suit Samus: 15
Knuckles the Echindna: 15
Bowser Jr.: 16
Maylene: 14
Misty: 14

Leon Powalski: 15
Kirby & the Amazing Mirror: 15
Fluttershy: 16
Pianta: 16
Ned's Declassified School Survival Guide: 18
Dr. Neo Cortex: 15
Meta Knight: 16
Toad: 15
Football Zombie: 16
Rarity: 16*4
Rouge the Bat: 15
Chandelure: 16
Sheik: 15
Skull Kid: 15
Spike: 16
Luigi: 15

Dead as a doornail
Wattson
Whittle
Danny
Pigma Dengar
Ray the Flying Squirrel
Starlow

Post count: 59
 
Banana on Maylene

Cole McGrath: 14
Nathan Drake: 15
Ganondorf: 15
Saria: 12
Zero Suit Samus: 15
Knuckles the Echindna: 15
Bowser Jr.: 16
Maylene: 10
Misty: 14
Leon Powalski: 15
Kirby & the Amazing Mirror: 15
Fluttershy: 16
Pianta: 16
Ned's Declassified School Survival Guide: 18
Dr. Neo Cortex: 15
Meta Knight: 16
Toad: 15
Football Zombie: 16
Rarity: 16*4
Rouge the Bat: 15
Chandelure: 16
Sheik: 15
Skull Kid: 15
Spike: 16
Luigi: 15

Dead as a doornail
Wattson
Whittle
Danny
Pigma Dengar
Ray the Flying Squirrel
Starlow

Post count: 60