| Member | Current Name | |
| Alexneushoorn | --> | Don Orbulon |
| Amphituber | --> | Waldotuber |
| aregularforumuser | --> | Luke Atmey |
| BabyLuigiOnFire | --> | Baby Luigi |
| Baby Mario Bloops | --> | Deku Link |
| Banjonator1 | --> | Banjo |
| BetaMaster64 | --> | MS-DOS |
| Boozooka | --> | Hitoshura |
| Bowser45 | --> | Nightmare Moon |
| Brock | --> | Naze Youka |
| Cackletta | --> | The Angel of Music |
| Cosmic Vin | --> | Vinnie |
| Count Bonsula | --> | The Happy Mask Salesman |
| Dr. Javelin | --> | Hawlucha |
| Edofenrir | --> | Gabumon |
| Epic Nitwit | --> | Pearl |
| Fantanoice | --> | Ema Skye |
| Fawfulthegreat64 | --> | Dimentio64 |
| FireEevee | --> | Sylveon |
| Freakworld | --> | BananaFreak |
| FrostyFireYoshi | --> | Guilmon |
| GalacticPetey | --> | ゴジラ |
| Gamefreak75 | --> | Cordelia |
| Gonzales Kart Inc. | --> | Police Squad! |
| Goomba | --> | Mr. Game & Watch |
| GrammarYoshi | --> | Elwood Blues |
| Hypnotoad | --> | Politoed |
| Iggy Koopa Jr | --> | Cucurbita Pepo |
| JohnRoberts | --> | Shrek Guy |
| Kingfawful4321 | --> | Hades |
| Lakituthequick | --> | Lakitulerapide |
| LeftyGreenMario | --> | Mario Party X |
| Lily x | --> | Klavier Gavin |
| Magikrazy | --> | Colonel Harland Sanders |
| Mason/Puddin | --> | Puddin |
| Master Crash | --> | Tharja |
| Marioman1213 | --> | Marilith |
| MarioMaster15/Vocal Beat | --> | Vocal Beat |
| Mariorules25 | --> | SuperMario25 |
| Mario vs. Luigi | --> | Ricken |
| Marshal Dan Troop/Shoey | --> | Corkscrew |
| MBV/DP | --> | Crocodile Dippy |
| Megadardery | --> | Mega |
| MrConcreteDonkey | --> | Dr. Lucien Sanchez |
| MST3K | --> | Mienfoo |
| Neptune | --> | Delelelele Whoop |
| NEXandGBX | --> | Phoenix Wright |
| OJ Toad | --> | Not Nuclear |
| Paper Yoshi | --> | Johnny Buckland |
| Pokémon Trainer Red | --> | Pikachu |
| PyroGuy6 | --> | Finland |
| Ralphfan | --> | Ralph |
| Recon-Seven | --> | Rekon-Sebun |
| Red Barchetta/Palkia | --> | Dean Winchester |
| Rocker64 | --> | Kimberly Hart |
| Scarecrow von Steuben | --> | Nice Cage |
| Skulldug13 | --> | Dryskull |
| Smasher | --> | Tailmon |
| Smiley | --> | Sergeant Sillies |
| Snowstalker | --> | Gummy |
| SolarBlaze | --> | Solar Blaze |
| SonicMario | --> | Northern Verve |
| SpinyMaster347 | --> | SpinyMaster |
| Stooben Rooben | --> | Stooben |
| Superfiremario | --> | Ephraim |
| superjeff64 | --> | Randy Cunningham |
| Super-Yoshi/tfp | --> | Minako Aino |
| Supremo | --> | Aegislash |
| TabuuOwnsAll132x2 | --> | Based Sora |
| Tantusar | --> | emotionTongue |
| Time Turner | --> | Reversinator |
| Toad85 | --> | キノピオ八十五 |
| Toadette and Koopa Lover | --> | Speedy Yoshi |
| ToxBox | --> | PlayStation 4 |
| Tucayo | --> | Hobbes |
| Twentytwofiftyseven/2257 | --> | Shoutmon |
| U freak | --> | Dimitri |
| Ultraluigi | --> | Moulder the Boulder |
| Unknown Entity | --> | Junko Enoshima |
| Xzealio | --> | Xzealia Exdementia |
| YamiHoshi | --> | MKGirlism |
| yoshi123 | --> | Timmy |
| Yoshi876 | --> | Demidevimon |
| YoshiKong | --> | Daskarzine |
| Zero777 | --> | Aquila |
Legend
- Bold indicates a Forum Moderator.
Credit to Smasher for helping out!
YOU'RE WELCOME BTW
Hi Smasher
gamefreak what happened to your conversation with yourself