Decade Top 10

[Hobbes]

As I know many people will be upset, here you can discuss about my top 10 and even post your own!

Article: http://www.mariowiki.com/MarioWiki:The_'Shroom/Holiday/Top_10

 

[Booman]

Most parts I agree, though LM should be swiched with SMG.

 

[Uniju]

imo Luigi's Mansion should be way down in 17 or something, and SMG should be on top, but I'm too lazy to make my own list.

 

[ralphfan]

No sports spin-offs in top 10?

And yeah, you should play TTYD.

 

[ShyGuy27]

PM64 as #1? Thank you so much.

 

[Hobbes]

No sports spin-offs in top 10?

ermm.... sorry, but they are not nearly that good.

PM64 as #1? Thank you so much.

np

imo Luigi's Mansion should be way down in 17 or something, and SMG should be on top, but I'm too lazy to make my own list.

well, in one of the firsts lists i made LM wasnt tehre, but by a weird reason i decided to put it there. Nice you read it UNi, I know you dont do that often

 

[Uniju]

I... I only read it because you posted it here.

 

[Hobbes]

I... I only read it because you posted it here.

lol :P anyways, its nice you read it.

 

[Jesus Freak]

SMG above BIS?

waitwut

 

[Booman]

SMG shouldn't even be on the list imo.

 

[Nerdy Guy]

SMG shouldn't even be on the list imo.

Give your reasons.

 

[Garlic Man]

In my opinion, SMG should be higher, Luigi's Mansion should be lower(In fact, not on the list), Melee should be on there(if we're counting non-Nintendo games), and I don't think the GBA remakes of SNES games should count. I would also throw Mario Kart Wii in the outer edge of the top 10, as well as Mario & Luigi 2. Additionally, I know many would disagree, but Super Paper Mario as well.

 

[Nerdy Guy]

Melee should be on there(if we're counting non-Nintendo games)

But Melee is a Nintendo game. I think it just got pushed off the list by SMG and other stuff.

 

[Garlic Man]

Melee should be on there(if we're counting non-Nintendo games)

But Melee is a Nintendo game. I think it just got pushed off the list by SMG and other stuff.

The publisher and the console are both Nintendo. I was actually referring to the developer, which was HAL for Melee and Sora for Brawl. And yeah, it did get pushed off the list, but that's why I think the GBA remakes shouldn't be on the list.

 

[Hobbes]

Yeah... I was not planning to include remakes, but the other staff guys told me it was fine, so I did. In the firs list I made, M&L 2 was in LM's place. Which MK? perhaps I should have put them as a whole....

 

[Garlic Man]

Yeah... I was not planning to include remakes, but the other staff guys told me it was fine, so I did. In the firs list I made, M&L 2 was in LM's place. Which MK? perhaps I should have put them as a whole....

I'd say MKWii. I think the only others in the decade are Double Dash and DS.

 

[Noahp89]

Honestly, I think that's a smart decision that spin-offs aren't on there.

I also agree with your lists. I enjoyed PM64, but I didn't find it to be the BEST game in the decade. Still great though, and pretty close to best, maybe.

 

[Garlic Man]

Spin-offs, remakes, or non-Mario games(SSB and such) not included:


10. Mario vs. Donkey Kong
9. Super Mario Sunshine
8. Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story
7. Super Paper Mario
6. Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time
5. New Super Mario Bros.
4. Paper Mario
3. Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga
2. Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door
1. Super Mario Galaxy

There's some games out there that I haven't played, like New Super Mario Bros. Wii. There's also a lot of RPG's on the list, but then again, if you think about it there really aren't a whole lot of true Mario games recently that aren't remakes or spin-offs.

Also, I just read the SMG section on your top 10, and bad things about it included: "Not very original story". But when it comes to platformers, it's always Bowser kidnapping Peach. :P

 

[Hobbes]

Nice list, well, I wouldn't agree much with SPM, but everyione has different thoughts

And yea, that is like the thing in common of the platfotmer games

 

[Booman]

SMG shouldn't even be on the list imo.

Give your reasons.

SMG is fail, that's why.

 

[Nerdy Guy]

SMG shouldn't even be on the list imo.

Give your reasons.

SMG is fail, that's why.

-_-

I meant be discriptive. What do you not like about it? :/

 

[ShyGuy27]

Oo, this is gonna get interesting.

 

[Lario]

SMG is just overrated.

 

[Garlic Man]

SMG is just overrated.

Meh, I liked it good enough. Amazing graphics considering it's Wii.

 

[Booman]

It's storyline is crazy. They added to many new items, and the controls are bogus.