"Good Game Bad Game" Suggestions

[jaffffey]

Anybody have good suggestions for "Good Game, Bad Game" on the Shroom?
Please do not suggest games in the following categories:
*Mario Kart
*Mario Party
*Mario Tennis
*Mario Baseball
NOTE: Topics do not specifically need to be part of a franchise, but must be moderately similar
P.S: I may also make Top 10 lists in the future, so suggest for that as well.

 

[Snowstalker]

Luigi's Mansion vs. Mario is Missing?

 

[Stooben]

MLSS vs Paper Mario

 

[EctoBiologist]

Super Mario Bros 3 vs SMW

 

[Snowstalker]

The problem is that PM and SMW are great games, as are SS and Mario 3.

 

[ShyGuy27]

The problem is that PM and SMW are great games, as are SS and Mario 3.

But we all know that PM>SS (I'm gonna get killed for that one) and SMB3>SMW (barely).

 

[[ohgodpleasedelete]]

The problem is that PM and SMW are great games, as are SS and Mario 3.

But we all know that PM>SS (I'm gonna get killed for that one) and SMB3>SMW (barely).

Protip: Don't pass off your opinion as common knowledge.

 

[Magitroopa]

PMTYD V.S. SPM.

 

[Snowstalker]

Again, both great games.

Why all the SPM hate? Just because it's different?

 

[Snowstalker]

Let's see...

By default, the best Mario plot
YOU PLAY AS BOOZUH
A sense of humor
Challenging, but not insane (I'm looking at you, TLL)
Fun gameplay
Decent music
Francis

 

[Stooben]

Take it to a Super Paper Mario thread.

 

[Snowstalker]

Challenging, but not insane (I'm looking at you, TLL)

...You where challenged by SPM?

Not by the main game, but I suck at puzzles, so...

 

[Yoshario]

Super Mario Galaxy and basically any Mario Party game.

 

[Glowsquid]

Super Mario Galaxy and basically any Mario Party game.

... Well, the games should be at least similar.

 

[Stooben]

How about SMB2 and TLL?

 

[Jesus Freak]

Brawl v.s. Melee?

 

[Snowstalker]

Both amazing games? No. Plus, Melee's better.

 

[Jesus Freak]

Both amazing games? No. Plus, Melee's better.

Hey, there are others with different opinions.

 

[Snowstalker]

Melee is better than Brawl.

1: Brawl somehow manages to be even LESS balanced. Melee had 4 characters dominating the tourney scene (Fox, Marth, Sheik, Falco). Brawl has 1 (Meta Knight).
2. Brawl replaced sweet combos with random, annoying tripping.

 

[jaffffey]

Melee is better than Brawl.

1: Brawl somehow manages to be even LESS balanced. Melee had 4 characters dominating the tourney scene (Fox, Marth, Sheik, Falco). Brawl has 1 (Meta Knight).
2. Brawl replaced sweet combos with random, annoying tripping.

No, since I like brawl 10x better than Melee.

 

[Jesus Freak]

Melee is better than Brawl.

1: Brawl somehow manages to be even LESS balanced. Melee had 4 characters dominating the tourney scene (Fox, Marth, Sheik, Falco). Brawl has 1 (Meta Knight).
2. Brawl replaced sweet combos with random, annoying tripping.

..........No input. Never played Melee.

 

[SiFi]

Melee is better than Brawl.

1: Brawl somehow manages to be even LESS balanced. Melee had 4 characters dominating the tourney scene (Fox, Marth, Sheik, Falco). Brawl has 1 (Meta Knight).
2. Brawl replaced sweet combos with random, annoying tripping.

No, since I like brawl 10x better than Melee.

That destroys the purpose of comparing a good game and a bad game.

Not that you did a very good job of it to start with.

 

[jaffffey]

Melee is better than Brawl.

1: Brawl somehow manages to be even LESS balanced. Melee had 4 characters dominating the tourney scene (Fox, Marth, Sheik, Falco). Brawl has 1 (Meta Knight).
2. Brawl replaced sweet combos with random, annoying tripping.

No, since I like brawl 10x better than Melee.

That destroys the purpose of comparing a good game and a bad game.

Not that you did a very good job of it to start with.

Okay, SHADDAP! I do the best I can! It's not like you have made a better section!

 

[Stooben]

Luigi's Mansion and Mario is Missing. (Was that already suggested?)

 

[Glowsquid]

Mario Time's Machine and Partner in Time.