M12 Favorite Supporting Character

Add "Boo" to M12?

  • Yes

    Votes: 4 28.6%
  • No

    Votes: 8 57.1%
  • Abstain

    Votes: 2 14.3%

  • Total voters
    14

Anton

kero?
Chat Administrator
Core 'Shroom Staff
Awards Committee
Because the vote was split the decision is now deferred to here, whether to add Boo to M12 or not.

[2017-03-17 18:35:21] <Anton{Politoed}> 4M11 Favorite Supporting Character (Princess Daisy, Waluigi, Toadsworth, Diddy Kong, Professor E. Gadd, Toadette, Captain Toad, Birdo, Kamek, Poochy)
[2017-03-17 18:35:23] <shoutmon> 7and he has a more major role in his series than poocy does
[2017-03-17 18:35:31] <turb> add doopliss
[2017-03-17 18:35:37] <turb> no but actually idk anything off the top of my head
[2017-03-17 18:35:39] <shoutmon> 7seriously though, boo
[2017-03-17 18:35:42] <Lord_Bowser> kammy?
[2017-03-17 18:35:43] <Anton{Politoed}> 4 9) Toadsworth — 106 — 4.02% 10) Birdo — 75 — 2.84% 11) O. Starlow — 7 — 0.27% 12) O. Boo — 3 — 0.11%
[2017-03-17 18:35:51] <Superchao> add reimu
[2017-03-17 18:35:51] <Freakworld> leave as is
[2017-03-17 18:35:53] <shoutmon> 7boo has an amiibo and is therefore important
[2017-03-17 18:35:55] <DragonFreak> 6maybe we could add poochy to this like what turb just said
[2017-03-17 18:35:59] <turb> poochy is on this
[2017-03-17 18:36:02] <Superchao> poochy is on this
[2017-03-17 18:36:04] <Freakworld> ok per reimu
[2017-03-17 18:36:08] <shoutmon> 7poochy is on this
[2017-03-17 18:36:14] <turb> i was saying add diddy/poochy to major if that happens down the line
[2017-03-17 18:36:16] <DragonFreak> 6oh lol
[2017-03-17 18:36:17] <turb> anyway
[2017-03-17 18:36:26] <turb> uh, i dont really want to add starlow but my opinion doesnt really matter
[2017-03-17 18:36:37] <turb> but i guess we can't necessarily add boo but not her if we go solely off of votes
[2017-03-17 18:36:38] <Superchao> i don't think 7 votes is worth adding
[2017-03-17 18:36:39] * DragonFreak 6cowers in fear of starlow
[2017-03-17 18:36:41] <turb> boo does have an amiibo
[2017-03-17 18:36:42] <Superchao> oh
[2017-03-17 18:36:53] <Superchao> i don't really know that an amiibo's existence is a strong argument
[2017-03-17 18:37:19] <Anton{Politoed}> 4why does boo have an amiibo
[2017-03-17 18:37:24] <Anton{Politoed}> 4let's look that up
[2017-03-17 18:37:34] <shoutmon> 7ive been wondering that since the first day of time
[2017-03-17 18:37:36] <Lord_Bowser> i think it's playable in mp10
[2017-03-17 18:37:43] <Nyrie> boo is in a lot of spinoffs
[2017-03-17 18:37:45] <shoutmon> 7but it does, so clearly its an important character
[2017-03-17 18:37:45] <Superchao> by that token, couldn't we justify adding Dr. Mario
[2017-03-17 18:37:48] <Nyrie> especially sports games
[2017-03-17 18:37:58] <Nyrie> its not in mp10 it was in star rush
[2017-03-17 18:38:06] <Lord_Bowser> oh
[2017-03-17 18:38:09] <Anton{Politoed}> 4mario party looks like it
[2017-03-17 18:38:13] <turb> is there one dedicated boo character
[2017-03-17 18:38:16] <Anton{Politoed}> 4star rush and mp10
[2017-03-17 18:38:18] <shoutmon> 7is dr mario a character or is he just mario wearing a costume
[2017-03-17 18:38:18] <turb> like birdo and kamek
[2017-03-17 18:38:20] <Anton{Politoed}> 4http://www.nintendo.com/amiibo/detail/boo-amiibo-super-mario-series
[2017-03-17 18:38:30] <Nyrie> boo is like toad i think
[2017-03-17 18:38:42] <shoutmon> 7captain boo: treasure tracker
[2017-03-17 18:38:46] <meowth> 12i'm iffy on both boo and dr. mario
[2017-03-17 18:38:48] <meowth> 12i'd buy that
[2017-03-17 18:38:50] <shoutmon> 7i would play it
[2017-03-17 18:39:05] <shoutmon> 7would boo knock itself out with its own headlamp tho
[2017-03-17 18:39:09] <Nyrie> Is There Even A Specific Toad Character? ? ?
[2017-03-17 18:39:11] <Lord_Bowser> idk about dr mario but i wouldn't mind seeing boo
[2017-03-17 18:39:37] -->| Freakworld_ (Freakworld@a7qnkbo41.dyn.telefonica.de) has joined #mwikiawards
[2017-03-17 18:39:49] <Freakworld_> [02:38] Freakworld dont add boo
[2017-03-17 18:39:51] <Freakworld_> [02:38] Freakworld if thats the case we could also add say
[2017-03-17 18:39:52] <shoutmon> 7im not convinced there actually is someone just named "toad"
[2017-03-17 18:39:53] <Freakworld_> [02:38] Freakworld hammer bro
[2017-03-17 18:39:54] <Freakworld_> [02:38] Freakworld blooper
[2017-03-17 18:39:56] <Freakworld_> [02:38] Freakworld chargin chuck
[2017-03-17 18:40:08] <shoutmon> 7smrpg is the only game that really seems to imply that
[2017-03-17 18:40:09] <turb> is favorite major character collapsing at the seams
[2017-03-17 18:40:13] <turb> also now that i think about it yeah
[2017-03-17 18:40:15] <turb> favorite enemy
[2017-03-17 18:40:19] |<-- Freakworld has left irc.darkmyst.org (Killed (NickServ (GHOST command used by Freakworld_)))
[2017-03-17 18:40:20] <shoutmon> 7with one specific toad having toad on all his dialog boxes
[2017-03-17 18:40:20] <turb> but birdo and kamek are also enemies i guess
[2017-03-17 18:40:21] <Anton{Politoed}> 4yeah I believe Boo still solidly fits into enemy yeah
[2017-03-17 18:40:25] <turb> idk
[2017-03-17 18:40:25] <shoutmon> 7and all the others being unnamed
[2017-03-17 18:40:30] =-= Freakworld_ is now known as Freakworld
[2017-03-17 18:40:36] <turb> if i had to choose one or the other for boo i would put it in enemy
[2017-03-17 18:40:36] =-= Mode #mwikiawards +o Freakworld by ChanServ
[2017-03-17 18:40:43] <Anton{Politoed}> 4kamek at least in the english games is like
[2017-03-17 18:40:53] <Anton{Politoed}> 4a separate entity from magikoopas in stages
[2017-03-17 18:40:55] <turb> yeah
[2017-03-17 18:41:02] <Superchao> birdo and kamek are pretty heavily shown to be specific entities i feel
[2017-03-17 18:41:11] <Freakworld> y
[2017-03-17 18:41:11] <shoutmon> 7replace favorite smash character with favorite boo
[2017-03-17 18:41:15] <Anton{Politoed}> 4whether or not he actually has a name that's not his species
[2017-03-17 18:41:18] <DragonFreak> 6good idea 22
[2017-03-17 18:41:19] <Anton{Politoed}> 4he's still an individual
[2017-03-17 18:41:25] <Freakworld> i vote gameboo advance
[2017-03-17 18:41:32] <DragonFreak> 6i vote for the blindfolded hordes of boos in super princess peach
[2017-03-17 18:41:33] <Lord_Bowser> why not turboo
[2017-03-17 18:41:36] <Anton{Politoed}> 4as for now though, to pick up the pace
[2017-03-17 18:41:37] <Superchao> i vote turboo
[2017-03-17 18:41:39] <Superchao> dammit
[2017-03-17 18:41:41] <Freakworld> turboo is fake and gay
[2017-03-17 18:41:47] <Superchao> wow rude
[2017-03-17 18:41:51] <Anton{Politoed}> 4Vote: Add "Boo" to M12? (Y/N/A)
[2017-03-17 18:41:52] <turb> if you put favorite boo as an award to replace smash character people probably would meme me into first
[2017-03-17 18:41:54] <turb> a
[2017-03-17 18:41:54] <Freakworld> n
[2017-03-17 18:41:56] <Superchao> n
[2017-03-17 18:42:02] <shoutmon> 7y
[2017-03-17 18:42:02] <Lord_Bowser> a
[2017-03-17 18:42:05] <DragonFreak> 6y
[2017-03-17 18:42:07] <Lakituthequick> y
[2017-03-17 18:42:14] <Superchao> well i mean
[2017-03-17 18:42:15] <Anton{Politoed}> 4n
[2017-03-17 18:42:18] <Superchao> it's basically you or king boo
[2017-03-17 18:42:21] <Meta_Knight> 10n
[2017-03-17 18:42:29] <Nyrie> y
[2017-03-17 18:42:30] <Freakworld> why no booigi
[2017-03-17 18:42:32] <Freakworld> *not
[2017-03-17 18:42:37] <turb> true
[2017-03-17 18:42:39] <Lakituthequick> >booigi
[2017-03-17 18:42:41] <Superchao> because nobody loves booigi
[2017-03-17 18:42:45] <shoutmon> 7boo + boo mushroom = boo boo
[2017-03-17 18:42:51] <meowth> 12a
[2017-03-17 18:42:54] <Lakituthequick> Booigi's Mansion: Blue Moon
[2017-03-17 18:42:59] <meowth> 124-4-3
[2017-03-17 18:43:00] <Anton{Politoed}> 4are there any other votes
[2017-03-17 18:43:01] <meowth> 12well
[2017-03-17 18:43:16] <shoutmon> 7ill vote again if you want
[2017-03-17 18:43:19] <Lakituthequick> BM:BM
[2017-03-17 18:43:29] <shoutmon> 7bmb?
[2017-03-17 18:43:37] <DragonFreak> 6yes
[2017-03-17 18:43:39] <Lakituthequick> sure why not
[2017-03-17 18:43:40] <Anton{Politoed}> 4this is an indecision and I'll make YET ANOTHER forum topic about this
[2017-03-17 18:43:42] <Freakworld> bmb: the new horror game
[2017-03-17 18:43:59] <turb> yeah i genuinely dont really feel strongly enough either way to change my vote
[2017-03-17 18:44:05] <turb> i could switch to N but even then it would be 4-5
[2017-03-17 18:44:07] <turb> kinda too close
[2017-03-17 18:44:08] <Anton{Politoed}> 4is there anything else about M12 before we move onto the next award to also decide almost nothing on
[2017-03-17 18:44:11] <shoutmon> 7i just think
[2017-03-17 18:44:12] <Lakituthequick> inb4 46 new topics by 3am
[2017-03-17 18:44:12] <Freakworld> i feel a clear n
[2017-03-17 18:44:16] <shoutmon> 7worst case scenario
[2017-03-17 18:44:17] <Superchao> spooked my guts right out of my pockets
[2017-03-17 18:44:25] <shoutmon> 7boo does badly and we remove it next year
[2017-03-17 18:44:32] <meowth> 12i don't feel strongly either way either
[2017-03-17 18:44:36] <shoutmon> 7its not.... a big deal...
[2017-03-17 18:44:39] <Lord_Bowser> neither do i
[2017-03-17 18:44:44] <Anton{Politoed}> 4that's true but I don't want that to be a precedent for anything else
[2017-03-17 18:45:08] <Anton{Politoed}> 4is there anything else about M12
[2017-03-17 18:45:24] <Lord_Bowser> not that i can think of
[2017-03-17 18:45:26] <meowth> 12i see the points on both sides
[2017-03-17 18:45:31] <turb> no one actually wants to add starlow right
[2017-03-17 18:45:32] <meowth> 12was dr mario in consideration
[2017-03-17 18:45:32] <turb> i dont
[2017-03-17 18:45:37] <Anton{Politoed}> 4i don't
[2017-03-17 18:45:41] <shoutmon> 7no, boo is a way better sphere
[2017-03-17 18:45:43] <meowth> 12nope
[2017-03-17 18:45:49] <shoutmon> 7if we add starlow and not boo im gonna be mad
[2017-03-17 18:45:50] <Freakworld> starlow best mario waifu 2k17
[2017-03-17 18:45:51] <Lord_Bowser> destroy starlow
[2017-03-17 18:45:51] <DragonFreak> 6starlow makes me hide under my bed
[2017-03-17 18:45:59] <Anton{Politoed}> 4ok moving on
 

Kazooie

Red-crested Breegull
Chat Administrator
Core 'Shroom Staff
Awards Committee
Retired Wiki Staff
I voted "no" because Boo is much more consistently an enemy than he is an ally.
 

Lord Bowser

Super High School Level Bowser
Core 'Shroom Staff
Poll Committee
i can see both sides of the argument, amd both are pretty equally valid in my opinion, so i'm going to abstain for now since i'm pretty torn on the issue.
 

Petra Macneary

"The hated boss who beats you down..."
Forum Moderator
Chat Administrator
Core 'Shroom Staff
Awards Committee
Retired Wiki Staff
I like Boo, but I'm in the same boat as Edo.
 

Linhardt von Hevring

Shine Sprite
Wiki Administrator
Chat Administrator
Core 'Shroom Staff
Awards Committee
Abstaining for now, will likely change my vote later. It's not really a big deal to me whether it gets on the award or not, but I do usually view Boo as an enemy rather than as a consistent character like with Birdo. I guess an argument could be made to compare it to Toad on Favorite Major Character, since there's no real single character named Toad. He does have more weight in the series overall what with being in SM3DW and the like, though, and Boo's playable appearances are mostly relegated to spinoffs.
 
Top